Jump to content
Followers 0
Ryan

Your fave's critical, commercial and artistic peak?

By Ryan, in Battlegrounds

Recommended Posts

Ryan

Ryan 6,363

Posted
Posted


Which eras were your faves critical, commercial and artistic peak?

Critical: Their most acclaimed album/era
Commerical: Their most successful album/era
Artistic: In your opinion, their best album/era based upon the quality of the music

Gf5HrnW.gif


 

Link to post
Share on other sites
Alejandreaux

Alejandreaux 13,308

Posted
Posted

GAGA:

Critical: The Fame Monster
Commerical: The Fame
Artistic: Born This Way /  The Fame Monster

BEY:

Critical: BEYONCE
Commerical: Dangerously in Love
Artistic: BEYONCE

TAYLOR:

Critical: Speak Now
Commerical: 1989
Artistic: Speak Now

 

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
RihannaRTT

RihannaRTT 14,528

Posted
Posted

I don't agree with the artistic peak definition. Artistically, Katy's peak is One of the Boys, but her best album is Teenage Dream. There's a difference. Commercially TD and Critically PRISM. 

 

For Rihanna; Commercial - GGGB, Critical - Rated R, Artistic - Rated R (but personally GGGB). 

Link to post
Share on other sites
Carlos

Carlos 8,453

Posted
Posted

Critical: Honeymoon

Commercial: Born To Die

Artistic: Ultraviolence or Honeymoon

Uv and H could really get it tho, stay pressed BTD stans.

 

Critical: Prism

Commercial: Teenage Dream

Artistic: One Of The Boys

Basically what Paul said. @RihannaRTT

 

Critical: Unapologetic

Commercial: Loud

Artistic: Rated R

I'm mean come on.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Villanelle

Villanelle 5,143

Posted
Posted

BTW was not gagas best artistic era. Yes the tour was extremely original but TF/M was a HUGE artistic concept that defined her and will always be her go to era for comparisons

BTWga was exhausted by the end, TEOG, MTN and Y&I were a mess

She will never  beat any of the fame. The concept, the music, the looks, the videos, the performances-FLAWLESS

Link to post
Share on other sites
Iconic

Iconic 3,104

Posted
Posted
27 minutes ago, ICONICK said:

BTW was not gagas best artistic era. Yes the tour was extremely original but TF/M was a HUGE artistic concept that defined her and will always be her go to era for comparisons

BTWga was exhausted by the end, TEOG, MTN and Y&I were a mess

She will never  beat any of the fame. The concept, the music, the looks, the videos, the performances-FLAWLESS

well ,maybe not visually but musically BTW is superior and much more creative . Even though the concept of the album seems kind of basic, each song has a deeper meaning that adds to the final product and makes it more special. Lyrically ,Gaga was at her best and sonically it's more diverse and interesting than TFM.

Imo, Born This Way delivered most of Gaga's best songs but TFM delivered her best videos. 

1
Link to post
Share on other sites
Cloud-Ninetales

Cloud-Ninetales 4,761

Posted
Posted

To the Little Monsters saying BTW was her artistic peak. LMAOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

TFM was her artistic peak. I'm sorry, but Photoshopping your head onto a motorcycle is tacky, not artistic. It's try-hard and cringey. Using a picture you took of your computer screen of a cross and "Judas" in basic Impact font above it is not artistic. And finally, the artificial protrusions sticking out of her cheek bones that has nothing to do with being 'born this way' or shit. The bleached eyebrows, AWFUL makeup, stupid outfits, and music videos that ranged from way too over the top (BTW and MTN) to just plain boring and uninspired (TEOG).

You should be ashamed for calling that era more artistic than the visual masterpiece that is The Fame Monster. rav1 

1
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 27
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Followers 0
Go to topic listing

  • Browsing now   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×