Which FOTP fave, aside from Madonna, has had the best "reinventions"

[Melt Away 5,460]

On 12/2/2015, 8:16:59, Hylia said:

Just because Xtina's your fave doesn't mean you have to answer her, considering she's barely reinventive compared to some of the other girls

Sis......  

The only faves more reinventive than her are Madonna and barely Rihanna. Even Gaga doesn't stand a chance. Xtina has been reinventing herself since the beginning of her career, from clean teen star to promiscuous and colorful to a complete dirty slut to a sensitive mature image to a WW2 pin-up girl to a futuristic diva.... I could go on.

On 12/2/2015, 9:40:45, Hylia said:

Could non-Xtina stans even tell her albums apart? When it comes to the ballads they all sound like they're from the same album  

 

(I like Xtina though  

Debut is bubblegum pop, Stripped is a blend of rock/latin/hiphop/pop, B2B is very soul with lots of jazz influence, Bionic is electropop bangers and Lotus is basic  

Do you even know anything about her because I'm actually kinda offended by these claims...  

[Pikachu 399]

On December 3, 2015 at 2:16:30 PM, Devil Pray said:

Queen of reinvention went from Lizzy Grant to Lana Del Ray to Lana Del Rey to getting quieter and quieter with each album  

[xtinaslays 442]

"Xtina barely reinvents" sis bye

[Systemagic 5,459]

Christina's transitions from Debutina to Stripped, from Stripped to BTB and from BTB to KGB.

I don't know about Bionic though I mean I loved the album but it didn't have a strong personality a la Xtina or Baby Jane, and it was not cohesive when it comes to the music. It definitely wasn't "ahead of time" like she said but in her defense it was mostly or entirely RCA's fault.

Lotus didn't exist.

I hope X8 brings the reinvention back.

 

 

[Russian Roulette 5,988]

Katy

[Hylia 85,573]

8 hours ago, Mark said:

Sis......  

The only faves more reinventive than her are Madonna and barely Rihanna. Even Gaga doesn't stand a chance. Xtina has been reinventing herself since the beginning of her career, from clean teen star to promiscuous and colorful to a complete dirty slut to a sensitive mature image to a WW2 pin-up girl to a futuristic diva.... I could go on.

Debut is bubblegum pop, Stripped is a blend of rock/latin/hiphop/pop, B2B is very soul with lots of jazz influence, Bionic is electropop bangers and Lotus is basic  

Do you even know anything about her because I'm actually kinda offended by these claims...  

 

8 hours ago, xtinaslays said:

"Xtina barely reinvents" sis bye

Are y'all beating this dead horse on purpose or did you just not read my last posts in this thread?  

[Melt Away 5,460]

25 minutes ago, Hylia said:

 

Are y'all beating this dead horse on purpose or did you just not read my last posts in this thread?  

Didn't read, didn't know  I guess you're not alone on that anymore  

[Hylia 85,573]

Just now, Mark said:

Didn't read, didn't know  I guess you're not alone on that anymore  

I've been enlightened  

[Melt Away 5,460]

1 minute ago, Hylia said:

I've been enlightened  

You may order a copy of ha smash album Bionic on your way out  

[Hylia 85,573]

Just now, Mark said:

You may order a copy of ha smash album Bionic on your way out  

I actually own all ha albums from when I had some extra money once, I just haven't listened to them all yet  

[Melt Away 5,460]

Just now, Hylia said:

I actually own all ha albums from when I had some extra money once, I just haven't listened to them all yet  

mess

wanna donate them to me?  

 

 

waiT even lotus?  

[Skyline 16,075]

Christina followed by Rihanna followed by Gaga.

[Hylia 85,573]

1 minute ago, Mark said:

mess

wanna donate them to me?  

 

 

waiT even lotus?  

They're on iTunes, not physically  

 

Yeah, I don't get the hate towards it though? Bionic is clearly better though  

[Melt Away 5,460]

13 minutes ago, Hylia said:

They're on iTunes, not physically  

 

Yeah, I don't get the hate towards it though? Bionic is clearly better though  

Just like why ARTPOP is hated, it's basic, non-cohesive, pales in comparison to her previous albums and a mess in general, including with performances, promotion, etc. Also it's a massive flop  

[Angelus 11,476]

36 minutes ago, Hylia said:

They're on iTunes, not physically  

 

Yeah, I don't get the hate towards it though? Bionic is clearly better though  

When you listen Xtina's albums you'll realize why

 

Every Xtina album had theme and idea behind it, Lotus was just uninspired (it's not really bad), outdated and rushed.