Most talented at her peak: Britney or Katy?

[PhCh 3,209]

[Vesper 5,443]

Why is this even a question. Britney obviously.  

[Slasher 19,618]

Katy is the most talentless artist who has a section so...  

[jdpm1991 759]

This is an insult to Britney

[Mystique 7,665]

 

[Alejandreaux 13,308]

Britney was the better dancer/performer by FAR and she was able to produce iconic moments such as BOMT and Toxic

however Katy definitely is the better vocalist ( ) and she had more involvement with writing her songs...

i'd say overall Katy is slightly more musically talented (a "lesser of two evils" tea) but Britney was able to produce better material overall during her peak

[Vesper 5,443]

5 minutes ago, Alejandreaux said:

Britney was the better dancer/performer by FAR and she was able to produce iconic moments such as BOMT and Toxic

however Katy definitely is the better vocalist ( ) and she had more involvement with writing her songs...

i'd say overall Katy is slightly more musically talented (a "lesser of two evils" tea) but Britney was able to produce better material overall during her peak

All true tbh.  

[Philip 19,006]

Well, Britney at her peak excelled at dancing whereas Katy at her peak excels at nothing  

[VaginasAreDisgusting! 10,039]

Britney

[VaginasAreDisgusting! 10,039]

6 minutes ago, Alejandreaux said:

Britney was the better dancer/performer by FAR and she was able to produce iconic moments such as BOMT and Toxic

however Katy definitely is the better vocalist ( ) and she had more involvement with writing her songs...

i'd say overall Katy is slightly more musically talented (a "lesser of two evils" tea) but Britney was able to produce better material overall during her peak

OP meant talented overall, not musically 

Britney has a better and more unique voice than Katy 

and... 

3 minutes ago, Philip said:

Well, Britney at her peak excelled at dancing whereas Katy at her peak excels at nothing  

 

[Merryem 8,076]

23 minutes ago, Alejandreaux said:

however Katy definitely is the better vocalist (  )

bitch where??????

23 minutes ago, Alejandreaux said:

 and she had more involvement with writing her songs...

bitch where?!?!??!???!??!??!

[Alejandreaux 13,308]

Just now, Merryem said:

bitch where??????

bitch where?!?!??!???!??!??!

Katy's like a 4.5/10 while Britney is a 2/10

neither are great at all but Katy is, like i said, the lesser of 2 evils in that department imo 

 

[Crystal Whore 796]

Britney couldn't sing live but she could DANCE THE HOUSE DOWN and had iconic tunes in like, all five years of her peak? 

 

Katy cannot sing or dance. 

[Electric 2,071]

Exposing Votes: @Venus XCX voted Katy!

[Systemagic 5,459]

The one who wrote Everytime.

 

But seriously. Britney as a dancer/performer AND creative force during her peak, which was undoubtedly the In The Vatican era >>>

Sorry KatyScats. Your fave may be a more experienced songwriter although she gets lots of help from Boner McKnee and Dr Creep but she doesn't have anything that's half as good as In The Quran. And her performances are all garbage unless it's an acoustic show. At least Britney used to be a world class entertainer; we have yet to see that from Mediocrity Perry.

[Venus XCX 10,308]

24 minutes ago, Electric said:

Exposing Votes: @Venus XCX voted Katy!

What can I say, talent wins  

[Electric 2,071]

35 minutes ago, Venus XCX said:

What can I say, talent wins  

I'm glad you've seen the light at last!

[Systemagic 5,459]

38 minutes ago, Venus XCX said:

What can I say, talent wins  

And it's winning by a landslide

[Gilly 12,318]

britney by FAR

[Agugaga 1,337]

Britney was never talented. She was just a good dancer at one point for like 1.5 years, and her fans though they could build an icon legacy out of that period in time  

 

At least Katy knows how to write music and she does have a better voice than Britney, even though that's like saying piss is better than shit.