Do Gaga fans think they can come for Xtina?

[ChooseyLover 19,970]

Just now, SkullDrag said:

No it doesn't  Gaga is more iconic, her big songs actually going #1 >>>

Billboard Hot 100 Artists - All Time

#68 Lady Gaga

Christina Aguilera - FAILED TO CHART

Billboard 200 Artists - All Time

#98 Lady Gaga

Christina Aguilera - FAILED TO CHART

Gaga is bigger on both platforms, hits and albums  

Not when Xtina sold the double amount of album copies.  Her voice is one of the best voices of all time according to Rolling Stones (Gaga - FAILED TO CHART), her performances are as iconic as Gaga's, her contribution to music is huge indeed. And that's undeniable!

[SkullDrag 396]

Just now, ChooseyLover said:

Not when Xtina sold the double amount of album copies.  Her voice is one of the best voices of all time according to Rolling Stones (Gaga - FAILED TO CHART), her performances are as iconic as Gaga's, her contribution to music is huge indeed. And that's undeniable!

Yeah because of the era of albums sales, the Billboard All Time charts is adjusted and Gaga ends up on top!

[ChooseyLover 19,970]

1 minute ago, SkullDrag said:

Yeah because of the era of albums sales, the Billboard All Time charts is adjusted and Gaga ends up on top!

Yeah and where is Britney in that list? Because if she's under Gaga I know a thing or two I could do with that list, maybe clean my dog's poop with it  

[Strigoi 923]

3 hours ago, Benji said:

its not fair to compare those now, pretty sure xtincta still was bigger than gaga 8 years into her career. gaga is a flop rn. 

Possibly. But I have to disagree with Gaga being a flop. The fact that she is still mentioned to this level means that's she's relevant enough for discussion, and she HAS bounced back from SHITPOOP better than any of us expected. 

I think haters will have their time to shine if LG5 flops worse than SHARTQUEEF. But again, I think all of the fanbases need to humble themselves out a bit. Monsters talked a big game when Gaga was on top, and BAM, she fell. Kats are talking major smack now that Katy's on top but what happens if the GP doesn't like her more mature sound? 

I want everyone to succeed and everyone to make a good record. My whole point though was that no one has a right to say anything about another's fave because each fave has their downfalls. No one is strictly successful. 

[SkullDrag 396]

Just now, ChooseyLover said:

Yeah and where is Britney in that list? Because if she's under Gaga I know a thing or two I could do with that list, maybe clean my dog's poop with it  

Britney is in the Top 40 actually @ #38  

[Bionic Monster 5,020]

Gaga is still relevant, just not as much as she was at her peak. Was Christina equally popular in 2002 and 2007?

It also goes without saying that Gaga made more of an impact in her 3.5 year peak than Christina did before Gaga ended her in 2010. I stan both, but it's just a fact.

[jdpm1991 759]

23 minutes ago, ChooseyLover said:

Only this song has had more impact than anything Gaga has ever done

And Gaga still has more grammys and success than Xtinct

[ChooseyLover 19,970]

3 minutes ago, jdpm1991 said:

And Gaga still has more grammys and success than Xtinct

Britney only has one Grammy and her impact is three hundred times bigger than Gaga's. Your point? 

So a 5 years old career is what's called success now? Good to know 

[Holiest Dreams 179,461]

Isn't Gaga worth like 2-3x as much as Xtincta is? yeah then poor gagz i guess, queen xtincta wins!!1!!1 

[Infrared 20,649]

15 minutes ago, rocky road said:

so a greatest hits album with just Xtina's name on it + a top 10 hit doesn't count as career success, but a duet album with the legendary tony bennet does? I see you manipulating that goal post 

 

again, talk to me when shes still getting certified albums and top 10's and grammys 10 years in

 

also xtina's The Voice spot >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> gaga's role on AHS

 

also xtina's jazz album was much more successful than caca's and lead to an actual best-selling arena tour

 

 

literally what type of delusion 

 

Back To Basics was marketed as a Pop and R&B album with Jazz influences. C2C is a traditional actual jazz album full of standards to great legends. 

Some of ya'll girls really need a basic music education  

 

Keeps Getting Better was 9 years in, so we're really not that far from it, especially with LG5 coming out at the end of the year  

[Pierrot 54]

an agugaga topic right after I started posting again  

[Infrared 20,649]

1 minute ago, ChooseyLover said:

Britney only has one Grammy and her impact is three hundred times bigger than Gaga's. Your point? 

So a 5 years old career is what's called success now? Good to know 

 

I mean the Grammy foundation seems to think so, you know the governing body of music   

 

[ChooseyLover 19,970]

1 minute ago, Infrared said:

I mean the Grammy foundation seems to think so, you know the governing body of music   

 

Fucking Taylor Swift has more than 10 Grammys so I don't give a fuck about them sorry

How many Grammys have Kylie? Britney? Michael Jackson? Madonna? Less than Taylor Swift

[Skyline 16,075]

People saying that Gaga's career is "dead"  Even Xtina's career isn't "dead"

Gaga experienced an underperformance with ARTPOP in 2013 but the album still sold over 2 million worldwide and "Applause" was a worldwide hit no matter how you try to spin it. The ARTRAVE tour sold out on most dates so clearly her career isn't "dead" or "over"  However there is a lot of pressure on her to do well with LG5 otherwise she'll struggle to have a long career on the charts and maintain popularity 

Christina could also make a comeback but she's too lazy and currently focused on The Voice, if she has the right material than she can make a comeback (more likely to happen with a strong ballad). If she serves good music, the GP will be here for it. 

Just because they're not as popular as they were during their peaks doesn't mean they are "over"  They are still relevant to some degree but lbr Gaga has a stronger chance of a comeback because her underperformance is more recent and also she's making more effort to make a comeback than Xtina is

[Infrared 20,649]

4 minutes ago, ChooseyLover said:

Fucking Taylor Swift has more than 10 Grammys so I don't give a fuck about them sorry

How many Grammys have Kylie? Britney? Michael Jackson? Madonna? Less than Taylor Swift

 

Irrelevant user on a pop forum or music industry professionals

 

Grammy's dont have to be a factor, but its obvious the recognition is there. 

 

 

[Infrared 20,649]

2 minutes ago, Skyline said:

People saying that Gaga's career is "dead"  Even Xtina's career isn't "dead"

Gaga experienced an underperformance with ARTPOP in 2013 but the album still sold over 2 million worldwide and "Applause" was a worldwide hit no matter how you try to spin it. The ARTRAVE tour sold out on most dates so clearly her career isn't "dead" or "over"  However there is a lot of pressure on her to do well with LG5 otherwise she'll struggle to have a long career on the charts and maintain popularity 

Christina could also make a comeback but she's too lazy and currently focused on The Voice, if she has the right material than she can make a comeback (more likely to happen with a strong ballad). If she serves good music, the GP will be here for it. 

Just because they're not as popular as they were during their peaks doesn't mean they are "over"  They are still relevant to some degree but lbr Gaga has a stronger chance of a comeback because her underperformance is more recent and also she's making more effort to make a comeback than Xtina is

 

Exactly. I find it funny how people subtract numbers  

Do you guys subtract every time Madonna and Mariah flop or underperform.

 

30 years - Rebel Heart, MDNA, and American Life, Erotica 

[Gilly 12,318]

considering Gaga is worth more and ECLIPSED Xtinas ENTIRE career in the time span of 2 albums, yes, we can  not to mention she's more talented too  

[Gilly 12,318]

1 hour ago, SkullDrag said:

It doesn't matter if Gaga's career was shorter. Gaga achieved more in the first three years of her career than Xtina has in all her years. Plain and simple. The Fame has more impact than Xtina's whole career, and I aint even exaggerating  

this and anyone who doesn't see this is fucking deluded  

[Alejandreaux 13,308]

1 hour ago, 1997 said:

I don't really see what your problem is. Xtina's career was literally from 1999-2006

7 years. 

 

Gaga's career has lasted 2008-2016 

8 years. 

 

And Gaga is still keeping her self relevant without having to sit in a chair. Even during her floppy-ist moments she had 2 number one albums, 2 top ten songs, 2 successful tours, 5 critically acclaimed performances, and an emmy for her role on an actual TV show. 

 

So get over yourself. 

 

1 hour ago, 1997 said:

Well it's subjective. Yes, Keeps Gettin Better was a top 10 hit....off a greatest hits compilation. 

In terms of Xtina selling albums, going on tour, an actually being a relevant successful force her career lasted 1999-2006. Back to Basics was her last noteworthy effort. 

Gaga's career took off in 2008 and since then she's managed to keep herself successfully in the public eye for 8 years now. She had one commericall set back that had an opening week sales figure LARGER than both of Xtina's last 2 albums (opening week). 

I'm a casual Xtina fan, but coming for Gaga like Agu did was just hypocritical. Xtina is no better than Gaga. Then again...

At least Gaga's performances don't get cancelled....

At least Gaga still goes on tour....

At least Gaga can actually land a real Tv role and win for it....

At least Gaga can still get a number one album off a floppy pop album and a side jazz project...

 

 

1 hour ago, Infrared said:

Gaga has surpassed Xtincta in every category  

 

Didn't fuck up the national anthem for one. I mean really now bitch  

Bigger singles locally and worldwide

Bigger tours. Has Xtincta had a tour gross over 100 M yet?

Bigger success Grammy wise, having a Grammy in Pop, Traditional Pop, and Dance, a Grammy Foundation award, and 3 out 4 albums nominated for album of the year CONSECUTIVE   

A lead for a tv show with A Golden Globe  

Bigger social presence  

More awards just in general including CDFA, Billboard Woman of The Year, and Contemporary Songwriting Awards - All icon awards  

More records now  

 

All in less time  

 

 

 

not this thread being CANCELLED within the first 10 posts, i live

 

[rocky road 834]

1 hour ago, 1997 said:

Well a lot of things ride on LG5 believe it or not, it will determine if she's the next Xtina in terms of floppage. (Though I mean I hope Xtina CAN make a musical comeback)

Eitherway, i've never been one to be fixated about success and stan wars. I love Stripped and Back to Basics as much as I love TFM and BTW. I don't care if LG5 flops for filth as long as it's a great album, unlike ARTPOP.

Again my point is that no one has room to come for anyone. Each artists has their triumphs and failure. I'm perfectly aware of mine, but I would hope that you and Agu understand that your fave has hers. 

 

she wishes she was the next xtina in terms of floppage, that would mean she had a 10 years clean streak with ALL her songs charting

 

Britney pink Jessica etc were floppin early on lmao xtina had to become lazy 12 years in for her to finally flp