Music vs American Life

[Chris 59,195]

On 8/21/2016 at 2:26 PM, The Black Parade said:

Music vs American Life (tie  )

Impressive Instant vs Hollywood

Runaway Lover vs I'm So Stupid

I Deserve It vs Love Profusion

Amazing vs Nobody Knows Me

Nobody's Perfect vs Nothing Fails

Don't Tell Me vs Intervention

What It Feels Like For A Girl vs X-Static Process

Paradise (Not For Me) vs Mother and Father

Gone vs Die Another Day

American Pie vs Easy Ride

 

 

lemme re do  

 

 

Music vs American Life

Impressive Instant vs Hollywood

Runaway Lover vs I'm So Stupid

I Deserve It vs Love Profusion

Amazing vs Nobody Knows Me

Nobody's Perfect vs Nothing Fails

Don't Tell Me vs Intervention

What It Feels Like For A Girl vs X-Static Process

Paradise (Not For Me) vs Mother and Father

Gone vs Die Another Day

American Pie vs Easy Ride

 

[Pattern Walks 1]

Music vs American Life

Impressive Instant vs Hollywood

Runaway Lover vs I'm So Stupid

I Deserve It vs Love Profusion

Amazing vs Nobody Knows Me

Nobody's Perfect vs Nothing Fails

Don't Tell Me vs Intervention

What It Feels Like For A Girl vs X-Static Process

Paradise (Not For Me) vs Mother and Father

Gone vs Die Another Day

American Pie vs Easy Ride

 

American Life: 7

Music: 4

 

I was definitely more of a fan of Music in the past but recently listening to it I feel it hasn't aged as well as American Life. Listening back it seems like American Life takes all the musical ideas put forth in Music and executes them better. I think we can all agree SOMEONE needs to PLEASE PUT MADONNA BACK IN TOUCH WITH MIRWAIS ASAP!!!

 

[KissingGod 10]

The albums are like sisters, lmao.

 

Music vs American Life

Impressive Instant vs Hollywood

Runaway Lover vs I'm So Stupid

I Deserve It vs Love Profusion

Amazing vs Nobody Knows Me

Nobody's Perfect vs Nothing Fails

Don't Tell Me vs Intervention

What It Feels Like For A Girl vs X-Static Process

Paradise (Not For Me) vs Mother and Father

Gone vs Die Another Day

American Pie vs Easy Ride

 

American Life: 7

Música: 4

[Django 334]

I could never do that!!! DDDDDD:

 

Both are PERFECT ALBUMS. The only problem with both was that there should have been more singles and videos released:

 

Music shouldn't have stopped after WIFLFAG and released Impressive Instant with another great video.

 

American Life had also great singles and videos (AL original, DAD, Hollywood and even Love Profusion was good) but the fact that they didn't fight for Nothing Fails with a video and promotion is a lost oportunity.

 

Both album had good single choices but they could have been better handled after the 3rd single.

 

I know that's not the purpose of the thread, but I don't care.

 

 

[TASparkq 37]

There is no way I can choose between Don't Tell Me or Intervention; the rest was a sinch!

 

Music vs American Life

Impressive Instant vs Hollywood

Runaway Lover vs I'm So Stupid

I Deserve It vs Love Profusion

Amazing vs Nobody Knows Me

Nobody's Perfect vs Nothing Fails

Don't Tell Me vs Intervention

What It Feels Like For A Girl vs X-Static Process

Paradise (Not For Me) vs Mother and Father

Gone vs Die Another Day

American Pie vs Easy Ride

 

[Ultra Blue 551]

Music vs American Life

Impressive Instant vs Hollywood

Runaway Lover vs I'm So Stupid

I Deserve It vs Love Profusion

Amazing vs Nobody Knows Me

Nobody's Perfect vs Nothing Fails

Don't Tell Me vs Intervention

What It Feels Like For A Girl vs X-Static Process

Paradise (Not For Me) vs Mother and Father

Gone vs Die Another Day

American Pie vs Easy Ride

 

Even when i cheat Music wins  

[Angelus 11,476]

5 hours ago, Ultra Blue said:

Music vs American Life

Impressive Instant vs Hollywood

Runaway Lover vs I'm So Stupid

I Deserve It vs Love Profusion

Amazing vs Nobody Knows Me

Nobody's Perfect vs Nothing Fails

Don't Tell Me vs Intervention

What It Feels Like For A Girl vs X-Static Process

Paradise (Not For Me) vs Mother and Father

Gone vs Die Another Day

American Pie vs Easy Ride

 

Even when i cheat Music wins  

That's because talent and quality always wins

[Ultra Blue 551]

1 hour ago, Li'l Sebastian said:

That's because talent and quality always wins

There's no denying that  

too bad 11 year old me was not gay enough to appreciate the one and only true Queen of Pop when Music was released  

[TASparkq 37]

I just want to add - I Deserve It is one of the best ballads of her career and Impressive Instant is the one song that got robbed as a single!

[ICEQueen 332]

I LOVE BOTH 

[Cher 2,163]

Music vs American Life

Impressive Instant vs Hollywood

Runaway Lover vs I'm So Stupid

I Deserve It vs Love Profusion

Amazing vs Nobody Knows Me

Nobody's Perfect vs Nothing Fails

Don't Tell Me vs Intervention

What It Feels Like For A Girl vs X-Static Process

Paradise (Not For Me) vs Mother and Father

Gone vs Die Another Day

American Pie vs Easy Ride

Music: 7

AL: 4

[Curtains 533]

Music vs American Life

Impressive Instant vs Hollywood

Runaway Lover vs I'm So Stupid

I Deserve It vs Love Profusion

Amazing vs Nobody Knows Me

Nobody's Perfect vs Nothing Fails

Don't Tell Me vs Intervention

What It Feels Like For A Girl vs X-Static Process

Paradise (Not For Me) vs Mother and Father

Gone vs Die Another Day

American Pie vs Easy Ride

 

Music: 7

AL: 4

Just like the MDNA vs Rebel Heart game, that was what I expected

[RoleModel 469]

Music vs American Life

Impressive Instant vs Hollywood

Runaway Lover vs I'm So Stupid

I Deserve It vs Love Profusion

Amazing vs Nobody Knows Me

Nobody's Perfect vs Nothing Fails

Don't Tell Me vs Intervention

What It Feels Like For A Girl vs X-Static Process

Paradise (Not For Me) vs Mother and Father

Gone vs Die Another Day

American Pie vs Easy Ride

[Violet 1,335]

Music vs American Life

Impressive Instant vs Hollywood

Runaway Lover vs I'm So Stupid

I Deserve It vs Love Profusion

Amazing vs Nobody Knows Me

Nobody's Perfect vs Nothing Fails

Don't Tell Me vs Intervention

What It Feels Like For A Girl vs X-Static Process

Paradise (Not For Me) vs Mother and Father

Gone vs Die Another Day

American Pie vs Easy Ride

[Joanna 1,543]

Music vs American Life

Impressive Instant vs Hollywood

Runaway Lover vs I'm So Stupid

I Deserve It vs Love Profusion

Amazing vs Nobody Knows Me

Nobody's Perfect vs Nothing Fails

Don't Tell Me vs Intervention

What It Feels Like For A Girl vs X-Static Process

Paradise (Not For Me) vs Mother and Father

Gone vs Die Another Day

 American Pie vs Easy Ride

 

Music: 4 

AL: 7 

[Chris 59,195]

3rd edit's a charm

 

Music vs American Life

Impressive Instant vs Hollywood

Runaway Lover vs I'm So Stupid

I Deserve It vs Love Profusion

Amazing vs Nobody Knows Me

Nobody's Perfect vs Nothing Fails

Don't Tell Me vs Intervention

What It Feels Like For A Girl vs X-Static Process

Paradise (Not For Me) vs Mother and Father

Gone vs Die Another Day

American Pie vs Easy Ride

Cyber Raga vs Your Honesty

[ICEQueen 332]

Music vs American Life

Impressive Instant vs Hollywood

Runaway Lover vs I'm So Stupid

I Deserve It vs Love Profusion

Amazing vs Nobody Knows Me

Nobody's Perfect vs Nothing Fails

Don't Tell Me vs Intervention

What It Feels Like For A Girl vs X-Static Process

Paradise (Not For Me) vs Mother and Father

Gone vs Die Another Day

American Pie vs Easy Ride