Britney more critically acclaimed than Xtina, why?

[Dita 5,091]

2 minutes ago, Nick said:

Christina Aguilera - Cute teen pop debut

Stripped - Incredible

Back to Basics - Incredible

Bionic - Horrible in the minds of critics/GP tho I love it so to me it's incredible

Lotus -  

Not counting any others bc we all know Mi Reflejo and My Kind of Christmas don't count  

 

BOMT - Cute teen pop debut

Oops - Good teen pop sequel

Britney - Very good, seeing some growth

In the Zone - Incredible

Blackout - Incredible

Circus - Good comeback

Femme Fatale - Great

Britney Jean -  

Glory - Amazing

 

Part of it is that Britney simply has more discography. She's also, in the public's mind, only had one truly bad album. Christina's had two in the eyes of the public. I don't like to compare them because I love them both for different reasons, but I will give it to Britney that she has a more consistent discography.

 

Yet you called 3 X albums incredible and only 2 Britney albums  

 

[Villanelle 5,143]

1 hour ago, Belinda said:

You stan Beyoncé so your music criteria is a joke tho, no wonder why you said this 

Bey is the most critically acclaimed female tbh lbr

[Radar 2,782]

27 minutes ago, Dita said:

 

Stop.

 

16 minutes ago, natalia said:

delete yourself from existence fat

 

sorry, just answering the question! please dont attack me!

[♚Missy♚ 5,883]

6 hours ago, idontthinkyouknownowimchec said:

because christina aguilera's music is very bad

Pretty much this! 

[natalia 761]

2 minutes ago, ♚Miss Wank$♚ said:

Pretty much this! 

why has no one bagged tagged and dragged this gwho stain thru filth yet?

[♚Missy♚ 5,883]

Just now, natalia said:

why has no one bagged tagged and dragged this gwho stain thru filth yet?

because i will always remain unbagged untagged and undragged!

[natalia 761]

1 minute ago, ♚Miss Wank$♚ said:

because i will always remain unbagged untagged and undragged!

i very much doubt that but you do you 

[♚Missy♚ 5,883]

Just now, natalia said:

i very much doubt that but you do you 

JoinedWednesday at 10:46 AM JoinedJune 21, 2015  

 

[natalia 761]

Just now, ♚Miss Wank$♚ said:

JoinedWednesday at 10:46 AM JoinedJune 21, 2015  

 

what does that have to do  with anything

you don't have to be registered to read this forum

[♚Missy♚ 5,883]

Just now, natalia said:

what does that have to do  with anything

you don't have to be registered to read this forum

Thanks for following my journey I guess!

[natalia 761]

Just now, ♚Miss Wank$♚ said:

Thanks for following my journey I guess!

you keep me entertained 

[Dita 5,091]

38 minutes ago, natalia said:

why has no one bagged tagged and dragged this gwho stain thru filth yet?

 

because  about him?

[light741 1,974]

Overall Britney has a solid discography and more cosistent than Xtina's, because of how many fillers xtina's last 2 albums have. But objectively speaking, Stripped is a far more consistent album than Britney's last 2 albums(i haven't listened to Glory yet). So the fact that Stirpped has that low score says something about the "objectivity" of critics sometimes. 

[Courtney Love 4,389]

6 hours ago, ICONICK said:

Bey is the most critically acclaimed female tbh lbr

Madonna sis  

[Courtney Love 4,389]

OT: Honestly because Britney's team was much smarter with picking a track list. Xtina's long albums will obviously end up unfocused and bloated. Britney's records are much more concise and easier to swallow

[light741 1,974]

2 minutes ago, Erotic said:

Madonna sis  

Violencia Rivas is the most acclaimed of all time.

[Courtney Love 4,389]

1 minute ago, light741 said:

Violencia Rivas is the most acclaimed of all time.

 

[light741 1,974]

1 minute ago, Erotic said:

 

She created Punk, so yes.

 

[natalia 761]

36 minutes ago, Dita said:

 

because  about him?

yeah but he's really annoying and he stans Gwen of all people

[Nick 374]

9 hours ago, Dita said:

 

Yet you called 3 X albums incredible and only 2 Britney albums  

 

I'd say amazing = incredible imo so for me they're tied with three incredible albums  

If Christina had more discography and didn't take 60 years to make one song, it might be different.