Jump to content
Agugaga

Better discography: Xtina vs. Gaga

Better discography  

61 members have voted

  1. 1. Better discography

    • Xtina
      28
    • Gaga
      33


Recommended Posts

Christina's only good album is stripped, I'll add B2B as well but I've never fully been through it jj2 

 

CA is incredibly basic, Bionic is a stain in her discography, and Lotus suffered between being generic and being not knowing what sound you want. I will say Xtina has better ballads by far, but bops go to Gaga.

 

I'll wait till Joanne comes out to fully decide so it's 5 for 5

Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, Infrared said:

Christina's only good album is stripped, I'll add B2B as well but I've never fully been through it jj2 

 

CA is incredibly basic, Bionic is a stain in her discography, and Lotus suffered between being generic and being not knowing what sound you want. I will say Xtina has better ballads by far, but bops go to Gaga.

 

I'll wait till Joanne comes out to fully decide so it's 5 for 5

Don't forget to include Cheek to Cheek ny12  

Also don't forget to include Tina's endless lineup of side singles, soundtrack songs and hit collabos. Those all count towards ha. rav2 

Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, Agugaga said:

Don't forget to include Cheek to Cheek ny12  

Also don't forget to include Tina's endless lineup of side singles, soundtrack songs and hit collabos. Those all count towards ha. rav2 

Didn't Born This Way : The Remix get "better" reviews than Stripped jj4 

This is why Metacritic is dumb.

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, Radio said:

Letting the critics make your decision I see

Df72ASt.gif

no just pulling out a valid reciept that makes sense with the thread

Df72ASt.gif

non-biased music critics (and not internet stans) seem to think gaga has been able to put together more quality albums throughout her career, thats all im saying

Df72ASt.gif

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, Adele said:

The Fame and BTW are better than anything Xtina has released so yeah. 

Su-Barbie-A's Avatar

Stripped is better than both,, especially considering how horribly those two Gaga albums have aged. nat1 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Albums wise;

Stripped

The Fame Monster

The Fame

Back to Basics

Born This Way

CA 

Bionic

Lotus

Art Pop

 

Side singles: Lady Marmalade, Burlesque OST, Say Something, Telepathy, etc. vs. Cheek to Cheek....Xtina wins. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, Agugaga said:

Stripped is better than both,, especially considering how horribly those two Gaga albums have aged. nat1 

Why do you fighters act like Stripped is all that? nat1 

That album has a few fillers and it didn't age that well.

The only xtinct album that still sounds fresh is BTB. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, Adele said:

Why do you fighters act like Stripped is all that? nat1 

That album has a few fillers and it didn't age that well.

The only xtinct album that still sounds fresh is BTB. 

Because it is, and has since been used as the playbook for pop girl goes sexual/mature.

Link to post
Share on other sites

In my opinion:

Born This Way > Back to Basics > Stripped > The Fame Monster > Bionic > ARTPOP > The Fame > Christina Aguilera > Lotus

Bionic would have been above TFM if it had been narrowed down to the best 12-14 songs.

I would say overall Xtina, but Gaga hasn't released an album as bad as Lotus rav2

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 61
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

The Fame and BTW are better than anything Xtina has released so yeah. 

Non-biased music critics also seem to think that Confident by Demi Lovato (74 in Metacritic) is better than the Fame and Born Ths Way (both 71 in Metacritic). I guess Demi's last album shits on  Gaga'

Letting the critics make your decision I see


  • Browsing now   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×