Jump to content
Agugaga

So, can we officially say Xtina was more successful than Gaga?

Who is more successful?   

34 members have voted

  1. 1. Who is more successful?

    • Xtina (1999-2008), + Hit collabo resurgence (2011-2014)
      14
    • Gaga (2009-2013) + Jazz artist
      20


Recommended Posts

I mean should this even be an argument?

Xtina has the longevity, sold more albums, and has more #1 hits.  Her and Gaga are tied with Grammys. And even after Bionic Xtina still found ways to be relevant and successful with hit collabos and The Voice. Gaga, not so much. xtina11 

 

Winner; Obviously Xtina. Gaga's 1 year of pop culture dominance doesn't make her the winner  here, sorry xtina11 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Gaga obviously. nat1 

Is it really worth mentioning that Xtina had more longevity when Gaga outsold her at the end of the day? nat1 

Did Xtina ever dominate pop culture tho? Gaga did,it didn't last long but she did dominate whereas Xtina was never really more successful than most of her peers if you ask me. nat1 

Xtina was NEVER more successful than Gaga,at least not when TF outsold any Xtina album and Gaga managed to outsold her WW in a shorter amount of time. nat2 

Link to post
Share on other sites

gagas peak was faster but 10x larger. Xtina was never the biggest star on the PLANET. Gaga was a GLOBAL PHENOMENON. She's made more money, sold more tickets, and sold 2/3 of Xtinas album sales in the first 3 years of her career, despite debuting in the piracy age. 

 

 

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, Gilly said:

gagas peak was faster but 10x larger. Xtina was never the biggest star on the PLANET. Gaga was a GLOBAL PHENOMENON. She's made more money, sold more tickets, and sold 2/3 of Xtinas album sales in the first 3 years of her career, despite debuting in the piracy age. 

 

 

 

 

Like Britney, during her peak she was never shadowed, she created the shadow. Xtina was in a shadow her whole career by Britney. Gaga was the Britney

Link to post
Share on other sites
54 minutes ago, Cady Heron said:

Like Britney, during her peak she was never shadowed, she created the shadow. Xtina was in a shadow her whole career by Britney. Gaga was the Britney

And then Gaga cast the shadow during the Bionic era laughcry1 Poor X can't catch a break!

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Cady Heron said:

Like Britney, during her peak she was never shadowed, she created the shadow. Xtina was in a shadow her whole career by Britney. Gaga was the Britney

like the legend status...nobody says these things but Britney stans

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 28
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

gagas peak was faster but 10x larger. Xtina was never the biggest star on the PLANET. Gaga was a GLOBAL PHENOMENON. She's made more money, sold more tickets, and sold 2/3 of Xtinas album sales in the

Comparing an artist that's been in the business since 1999, to one that only started her career is 2008 is laughable at best. Bless.

Gaga obviously.   Is it really worth mentioning that Xtina had more longevity when Gaga outsold her at the end of the day?   Did Xtina ever dominate pop culture tho? Gaga did,it didn't last


  • Browsing now   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×