Overrated and underrated single on every Madonna album?

[SeekingThrill 10,041]

This will be an "unpopular opinions" type of thread. Let's spill some tea.  

 

For every album!

Overrated:

Underrated:

[fab 22,502]

Rebel Heart: 

Overrated: Living For Love ig 

Underrated: Bitch I'm Madonna

 

[SeekingThrill 10,041]

Madonna -  Overrated: Borderline          Underrated: Burning Up

Like A Virgin -  Overrated: Like A Virgin          Underrated: Angel

True Blue - Overrated: Live To Tell            Underrated: True Blue

Like A Prayer - Overrated: -            Underrated: Keep It Together

Erotica - Overrated:  -           Underrated: Bye Bye Baby

Bedtime Stories - Overrated: Take A Bow          Underrated: Bedtime Story

Ray of Light - Overrated: Nothing Really Matters   Underrated: The Power of Good-Bye

Music - Overrated: Music            Underrated: What It Feels Like For A Girl

American Life - Overrated: Hollywood            Underrated: American Life

Confessions on a Dance Floor - Overrated: Hung Up      Underrated: Jump

Hard Candy - Overrated: Give It 2 Me     Underrated:  -

MDNA - Overrated:  Girl Gone Wild           Underrated: Give Me All You Luvin

Rebel Heart - Overrated: Bitch I'm Madonna    Underrated:  -

 

 

I am thinking about the ones where I didn't write anything.  

 

[Earth Ripper 4,994]

I mean, this doesn't really work, some albums just have only amazing singles and/or appropriate praise for them

Anyway, some underrated singles in chronological order, not per album just in general

. Who's That Girl (1987)
. Causing a Commotion (1987)
. The Look of Love (1987)
. Oh Father (1989)
. Keep It Together (1989)
. Hanky Panky (1990)
. Bad Girl (1993)
. Fever (1993)
. Rain (1993)
. Bye Bye Baby (1993)
. Love Don't Live Here Anymore (1996)
. American Life (2003)
. Get Together (2006)
. 4 Minutes feat. Justin Timberlake & Timbaland (2008)
. Give It 2 Me (2008)
. Miles Away (2008)
. Revolver feat. Lil Wayne (2009)
. Turn Up the Radio (2012)

And some overrated ones:

. Dress You Up (1985)
. Open Your Heart (1986)
. Take a Bow (1994)
. Frozen (1998)
. The Power of Good-Bye (1998)
. Nothing Fails (2003)
. Hung Up (2005)
. Sorry (2005)
. Celebration (2009)
. Masterpiece (2012)
. Hold Tight (2015)

It's not that I don't enjoy/love these (minus Hold Tight which is 100% garbage), it's just that I think people exaggerate a bit about their quality level

[Systemagic 5,459]

Tried playing this but stopped at Ray of Light

[Quicksand 86]

ANGEL

[Milk 6,560]

Madonna -  Overrated: Holiday          Underrated: Burning Up

Like A Virgin -  Overrated: Angel          Underrated: Dress You Up

True Blue - Overrated: Live To Tell            Underrated: True Blue

Like A Prayer - Overrated: -            Underrated: Keep It Together

Erotica - Overrated:  -           Underrated: Deeper And Deeper

Bedtime Stories - Overrated: -          Underrated: Human Nature

Ray of Light - Overrated: -   Underrated: Nothing Really Matters

Music - Overrated: Music            Underrated: Don't Tell Me

American Life - Overrated: American Life            Underrated: Hollywood

Confessions on a Dance Floor - Overrated: Get Together      Underrated: Sorry

Hard Candy - Overrated: 4 Minutes     Underrated:  Miles Away

MDNA - Overrated:  Give Me All Your Luvin'            Underrated: Masterpiece

Rebel Heart - Overrated: Bitch I'm Madonna    Underrated:  Ghosttown

[Vertigo-go 18,832]

Cherish should've been aborted as a SONG, let alone a single

 

La Isla ( ), Mexicoborder, Angel, Maternity Girl ( ) are all overrated, obvious choices.

 

 

* indicates me being shocked at my own opinion

[Courtney Love 4,389]

Overrated singles: Borderline, Open Your Heart, Bad Girl, Human Nature and Ghosttown.

Underrated singles: Angel and Keep It Together

[Freaky Prince 38,421]

On 2/25/2017 at 7:04 PM, Nocturn said:

Hard Candy - Overrated: Give It 2 Me     Underrated:  - MILES AWAY

[Courtney Love 4,389]

20 hours ago, Milk said:

Like A Virgin -  Overrated: Angel    

Most stan's straight up hate this  

[SeekingThrill 10,041]

6 hours ago, John Wayne said:

Honestly, all HC singles are overrated.  

[Saiga 16,485]

Madonna -  Overrated: Lucky Star       Underrated: Burning Up

Like A Virgin -  Overrated: Material Girl          Underrated: Angel

True Blue - Overrated: Open Your Heart            Underrated: Live To Tell

Like A Prayer - Overrated: Like A Prayer            Underrated: Cherish

Erotica - Overrated: Erotica           Underrated: Rain

Bedtime Stories - Overrated: Take A Bow          Underrated: Bedtime Story

Ray of Light - Overrated: Nothing Really Matters   Underrated: The Power of Good-Bye

Music - Overrated: Don't Tell Me            Underrated: What It Feels Like For A Girl

American Life - Overrated: Hollywood            Underrated: Nothing Fails

Confessions on a Dance Floor - Overrated: Hung Up      Underrated: Jump

Hard Candy - Overrated: Give It 2 Me     Underrated: Miles Away

MDNA - Overrated:  Girl Gone Wild           Underrated: Give Me All You Luvin

Rebel Heart - Overrated: Bitch I'm Madonna    Underrated:  Living For Love

[Cher 2,164]

Madonna -  Overrated: Everybody         Underrated: Burning Up

Like A Virgin -  Overrated: Like A Virgin          Underrated: Angel

True Blue - Overrated: La Isla Bonita            Underrated: True Blue

Like A Prayer - Overrated: Express Yourself           Underrated: Keep It Together

Erotica - Overrated: Erotica           Underrated: Bad Girl

Bedtime Stories - Overrated: Secret          Underrated: Bedtime Story

Ray of Light - Overrated: Nothing Really Matters   Underrated: The Power of Good-Bye

Music - Overrated: Don't Tell Me            Underrated: What It Feels Like For A Girl

American Life - Overrated: Nothing Fails            Underrated: Die Another Day

Confessions on a Dance Floor - Overrated: Sorry      Underrated: Get Together

Hard Candy - Overrated: 4 Minutes     Underrated: Miles Away

MDNA - Overrated:  GMAYL           Underrated: Turn Up the Radio

Rebel Heart - Overrated: Bitch I'm Madonna    Underrated:  Living For Love