Jump to content
Savage

Which FOTP fave is the complete package? [POLL]

PICK  

53 members have voted

  1. 1. WHO'S THE FULL PACKAGE IN YOUR OPINION?



Recommended Posts

Just now, Philip said:

um1 

i'm not laughing at the "fat" comment, i'm laughing because spencer called me pressed knowing i live for brit :) 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Fave name: Erika Jayne

Singing ability: (pass/fail) 

Dancing ability: (pass/fail) 

Performing live: (pass/fail) 

Songwriting skills: (pass/fail)

Touring: (pass/fail)

Ability to sell albums/singles : (pass/fail)

Having more than 5 memorable hits: (pass/fail)

Videography: (pass/fail)

playing instruments: (pass/fail)

Ability to have an interesting genuine personality: (pass/fail)

Ability to hire a good management team: (pass/fail)

Ability to have a unique sense of style: (pass/fail)

Originality: (pass/fail)

Social media presence: (pass/fail)

Streaming power: (pass/fail)

Natural Beauty: (pass/fail)

Personal life skills: (pass/fail)

Love life skills: (pass/fail)

financial status: (pass/fail) 

Business sense: (pass/fail)

Grammys: (pass/fail)

Ability to have a clean public profile: (pass/fail)

Ability to have her songs charting: (pass/fail)

ability to have solo hits: (Pass/fail)

Ability to remain relevant for over a decade: (pass/fail)

Having a legacy/influence *for older faves* : (pass/fail)

Making it to the top 10 of G.O.A.T. list *for older faves* : (pass/fail) 

*extra points

 

Image result for erika jayne gif

Link to post
Share on other sites

Fave name: Britney Spears

Singing ability: fail brit2 

Dancing ability: pass brit7 

Performing live: pass brit7 

Songwriting skills: pass brit7 

Touring: pass +extra point brit7 

Ability to sell albums/singles : pass +extra point brit7 

Having more than 5 memorable hits: pass

Videography: pass +extra points brit7 

playing instruments: fail (sure she plays piano but... brit10 

Ability to have an interesting genuine personality: pass +extra points brit7 

Ability to hire a good management team: fail brit2 

Ability to have a unique sense of style: pass brit7 

Originality: pass brit7 

Social media presence: pass brit7 

Streaming power: fail brit2 

Natural Beauty: pass brit7 

Personal life skills: fail brit2 

Love life skills: fail brit2 

financial status: pass brit7 

Business sense: pass brit7 

Grammys: pass brit7 

Ability to have a clean public profile: fail brit2 

Ability to have her songs charting: pass brit7 

ability to have solo hits: pass brit7 

Ability to remain relevant for over a decade: pass brit7 

Having a legacy/influence *for older fave: pass brit7 

making it to the top 10 of G.O.A.T. list *for older faves* : what is this? brit10 

 

Total: 22 brit10 

Link to post
Share on other sites

LEGENDLIE MINOGUESUS

Singing ability: PASS!

Dancing ability: moo3

Performing live: PASS!

Songwriting skills: PASS!

Touring: PASS WITH EXTRA POINTS!

Ability to sell albums/singles : PASS WITH EXTRA POINTS!

Having more than 5 memorable hits: PASS!

Videography: PASS WITH EXTRA POINTS!

playing instruments: fail

Ability to have an interesting genuine personality: PASS WITH EXTRA POINTS!

Ability to hire a good management team: PASS!

Ability to have a unique sense of style: PASS!

Originality: PASS WITH EXTRA POINTS!

Social media presence: fail

Streaming power: fail

Natural Beauty: PASS WITH EXTRA POINTS!

Personal life skills: PASS!

Love life skills: fail

financial status: PASS!

Business sense: PASS!

Grammys: PASS!

Ability to have a clean public profile: PASS!

Ability to have her songs charting: PASS!

ability to have solo hits: PASS!

Ability to remain relevant for over a decade: PASS!

Having a legacy/influence *for older faves* : PASS WITH EXTRA POINTS!

making it to the top 10 of G.O.A.T. list *for older faves* : PASS WITH EXTRA POINTS!

 

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Fave name: Beyoncé bey3

Singing ability: (pass/fail) 

Dancing ability: (pass/fail) 

Performing live: (pass/fail) 

Songwriting skills: (pass/fail) idk ayumi1

Touring: (pass/fail)

Ability to sell albums/singles : (pass/fail)

Having more than 5 memorable hits: (pass/fail)

Videography: (pass/fail) 

playing instruments: (pass/fail) i guess ayumi1

Ability to have an interesting genuine personality: (pass/fail) I wouldn't say she's that interesting ayumi1

Ability to hire a good management team: (pass/fail)

Ability to have a unique sense of style: (pass/fail)

Originality: (pass/fail)

Social media presence: (pass/fail)

Streaming power: (pass/fail) Tidal ayumi1

Natural Beauty: (pass/fail)

Personal life skills: (pass/fail)

Love life skills: (pass/fail)

financial status: (pass/fail) 

Business sense: (pass/fail)

Grammys: (pass/fail)

Ability to have a clean public profile: (pass/fail)

Ability to have her songs charting: (pass/fail)

ability to have solo hits: (Pass/fail)

Ability to remain relevant for over a decade: (pass/fail)

Having a legacy/influence *for older faves* : (pass/fail) 

making it to the top 10 of G.O.A.T. list *for older faves* : (pass/fail) 

Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, Vesper said:

Fave name: Britney Spears

Performing live: pass brit7 

Songwriting skills: pass brit7 

Ability to have a unique sense of style: pass brit7 

Originality: pass brit7 

Grammys: pass brit7 

 

oprah8

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, StrippedX said:
9 hours ago, Vesper said:

Fave name: Britney Spears

Performing live: pass brit7 

Songwriting skills: pass brit7 

Ability to have a unique sense of style: pass brit7 

Originality: pass brit7 

Grammys: pass brit7 

Performing Live:

 

 

 

Britney has many many many great live performances under her belt that some of these other faves could NEVER replicate (the difficulty of the choreography itself cuts out almost all of the faves here, lbr), so don't try it just because she's now not as sharp as she was in her prime. brit1

 

Songwriting: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Songs_written_by_Britney_Spears

 

More than some other faves can say. rih1

Ability to have a unique sense of style:

http://www.elle.com/fashion/news/g28685/britney-spears-style-evolution/?slide=3

http://www.eonline.com/videos/259484/5-celebs-who-were-inspired-by-britney-spears-style

Image result for britney spears school girlImage result for britney spears black laceImage result for britney iconic looksImage result for britney slave 4 uImage result for britney spears denimImage result for britney red catsuitImage result for britney iconic looksImage result for britney iconic looks

 

Too many iconic looks to count sis. brit7 

 

Originality: This is arguable, but I'd say she's the original teen idol of the 90s, and she has given us a lot of original content and ideas that were then copied / emulated by those influenced by her impact, so they can be considered "original". 

Musically:

Quote

Blackout’ predicted the current euro pop sound of music today with songs like ‘Piece Of Me’ and ‘Heaven of Earth’ but it also introduced a new sound to pop music and that was dubstep....

The song ‘Freakshow’ was the first song by any [mainstream] pop artist to even remotely experiment with the dubstep in their music. 

Quote

The song ‘Radar’ coined what is now considered ‘Robo Pop’ and open the doors for other girls in pop to follow. This impact can be seen in Ke$ha’s music where every one of her songs includes auto tuned vocals and also in Lady GaGa’s ‘Poker Face’. Now tell me before Britney, who else was using auto tune in their music aside from T-Pain?

Also HIAM:

http://www.mtv.com/news/1655718/britney-spears-hold-it-against-me-is-gonna-inspire-people-skrillex-says/

Quote

In many ways, Ms. Spears has served up a jam in line with popular music's current craze, EDM (electronic dance music), but make no mistake, "Against Me" is a hard-hitting thumper of a pop electro-house tune. What's especially unique about the Dr. Luke- and Max Martin-produced single is that, in typical trailblazing fashion, Spears has saluted the dance music world by including a section of dubstep in the surefire radio hit.

And don't forget her famous catchphrase:  ‘It’s Britney Bitch!’ brit0 

Definitely Original. brit11 

Grammys: 

Grammy Award for Best Dance Recording

2005  Britney Spears "Toxic"

 

Still counts. brit0 

Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, Vesper said:

Performing Live:

 

 

 

Britney has many many many great live performances under her belt that some of these other faves could NEVER replicate (the difficulty of the choreography itself cuts out almost all of the faves here, lbr), so don't try it just because she's now not as sharp as she was in her prime. brit1

 

Songwriting: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Songs_written_by_Britney_Spears

 

More than some other faves can say. rih1

Ability to have a unique sense of style:

http://www.elle.com/fashion/news/g28685/britney-spears-style-evolution/?slide=3

http://www.eonline.com/videos/259484/5-celebs-who-were-inspired-by-britney-spears-style

Image result for britney spears school girlImage result for britney spears black laceImage result for britney iconic looksImage result for britney slave 4 uImage result for britney spears denimImage result for britney red catsuitImage result for britney iconic looksImage result for britney iconic looks

 

Too many iconic looks to count sis. brit7 

 

Originality: This is arguable, but I'd say she's the original teen idol of the 90s, and she has given us a lot of original content and ideas that were then copied / emulated by those influenced by her impact, so they can be considered "original". 

Musically:

Original catchphrase:  ‘It’s Britney Bitch!’ brit0 

 

Grammys: 

Grammy Award for Best Dance Recording

2005  Britney Spears "Toxic"

 

Still counts. brit0 

But her latest LIVE performance was in like... the early 2000's? oprah8

Yes and those lyrics THOUGH. I WANNA DANCE TIL MY BODY ACHES. oprah8 The only songs she has credit on that I love are Everytime and Alien lol.

Iconic looks sure but I don't think they're original or uniqe oprah8

GrammyS though oprah8

Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, StrippedX said:

But her latest LIVE performance was in like... the early 2000's? oprah8

Yes and those lyrics THOUGH. I WANNA DANCE TIL MY BODY ACHES. oprah8 The only songs she has credit on that I love are Everytime and Alien lol.

Iconic looks sure but I don't think they're original or uniqe oprah8

GrammyS though oprah8

do xtina.

Link to post
Share on other sites
8 minutes ago, StrippedX said:

But her latest LIVE performance was in like... the early 2000's? oprah8

Yes and those lyrics THOUGH. I WANNA DANCE TIL MY BODY ACHES. oprah8 The only songs she has credit on that I love are Everytime and Alien lol.

Iconic looks sure but I don't think they're original or uniqe oprah8

GrammyS though oprah8

I don't see a stipulation on when a live performance suddenly stopped being counted for this poll? Do you? oprah8

Subjective opinion on the quality of her songwriting. NEXT. brit10 

Show me any other pop star that did a pony-tailed school girl look, or a red catsuit, or a complete denim look before Britney, and I'll take back this point. brit10 

Oh, so this list only counts faves who have won MORE than one Grammy? oprah8 Really sis? oprah8 P.S. Grammys is not designating that it's more than one grammy award, it's the way to refer to the award ceremony itself, even if it's technically wrong.  Just type in "Grammys" in google and you'll see even reputable news media sources using the plural as a description of the GRAMMY awards and not # of awards, which is supposed to be all caps anyway. It's either The Grammys, or The Grammy Awards, just like it's The Oscars, or The Academy Awards.  

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grammy_Award

Quote

The Grammys had their origin in the Hollywood Walk of Fame project in the 1950s.[

nat1 

Link to post
Share on other sites
15 minutes ago, Vesper said:

I don't see a stipulation on when a live performance suddenly stopped being counted for this poll? Do you? oprah8

Subjective opinion on the quality of her songwriting. NEXT. brit10 

Show me any other pop star that did a pony-tailed school girl look, or a red catsuit, or a complete denim look before Britney, and I'll take back this point. brit10 

Oh, so this list only counts faves who have won MORE than one Grammy? oprah8 Really sis? oprah8 P.S. Grammys is not designating that it's more than one grammy award, it's the way to refer to the award ceremony itself, even if it's technically wrong.  Just type in "Grammys" in google and you'll see even reputable news media sources using the plural as a description of the GRAMMY awards and not # of awards, which is supposed to be all caps anyway. It's either The Grammys, or The Grammy Awards, just like it's The Oscars, or The Academy Awards.  

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grammy_Award

nat1 

britney scored 18/28 (without extra points).

She's not the full package anyway, by scores and based on the poll, so it is what it is.

Link to post
Share on other sites
10 hours ago, Vesper said:

Personal life skills: fail brit2 

I don't agree to be honest. In 2007 yes but now it's been 10 years and she seems to have a handle on it and a good relationship with her kids. wub1 

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, NJ said:

do xtina.

what?

1 hour ago, Vesper said:

I don't see a stipulation on when a live performance suddenly stopped being counted for this poll? Do you? oprah8

Subjective opinion on the quality of her songwriting. NEXT. brit10 

Show me any other pop star that did a pony-tailed school girl look, or a red catsuit, or a complete denim look before Britney, and I'll take back this point. brit10 

Oh, so this list only counts faves who have won MORE than one Grammy? oprah8 Really sis? oprah8 P.S. Grammys is not designating that it's more than one grammy award, it's the way to refer to the award ceremony itself, even if it's technically wrong.  Just type in "Grammys" in google and you'll see even reputable news media sources using the plural as a description of the GRAMMY awards and not # of awards, which is supposed to be all caps anyway. It's either The Grammys, or The Grammy Awards, just like it's The Oscars, or The Academy Awards.  

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grammy_Award

nat1 

No but is Britney really the complete package when she is CLEARLY lacking in the singing department, performance department, awards department and quality songwriting? oprah8 

I didn't even go for my own #1 fave, Xtina, cause I know she is lacking in some parts. Beyoncé is the complete package, however.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 79
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

Who's the baddest pop girl, FOTPers? let's find out.   Beside the poll, I'd like for my fellow FOTPers to provide their opinions using this friendly template below:   Fave name:

She's so close.  

Fave name: Beyonce  Singing ability: (pass/fail)  Dancing ability: (pass/fail)  Performing live: (pass/fail)  Songwriting skills: (pass/fail)   Touring: (pass/fail) Abilit


  • Browsing now   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×