Jump to content
SeekingThrill

Delete one song from every Madonna album

Recommended Posts

EDIT: I'm not including any deluxe tracks.

 

Madonna - Think Of Me (Dido doesn't)

 

Like A Virgin - I don't know her so the whole thing. [emoji19]

 

True Blue - Jimmy Jimmy! Help Me, I'm Vomiting!

 

Like A Prayer - Dear Jessie, You Suck As Much As Jimmy

 

Erotica - Why's It So Flaccid

 

Bedtime Stories - Inside Of Me

 

Ray of God - Error 404

 

Music - I Deserve It (good song tho [emoji20])

 

American Life - Die Another Day (I love it but it's the only one that doesn't "fit spiritually" on this album, even if sonically it belongs there).

 

Confessions On A Dancefloor - Jump If You're Basic

 

Hard Candy - Delete 2night

 

MDNR - Superstar

 

Rebel Heart - Hold (My Pussy) Tight

 

 

Posted from my iPhone using the FOTP app

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

I Know It - The only acceptable answer. I will cut anyone who even dares to mention anything else! lj1 

Shoo-Bee-Doo - Out of all the fillers (aka. the last three tracks) by far the most unnecessary and dumb one. eve1 

Jimmy Jimmy - I don't mind but I mean...come on. This over some of the better outtakes? wendy4 

Dear Jessie - I love this song and was gonna pick Promise to Try originally but I think if you compare these two DJ is by far the more redundant one.

Waiting - The chorus almost entirely composed from a Justify My Love sample. wendy4 The song itself a total filler on an already overloaded album. The production sounding like a cheap B-movie porn soundtrack. I'm sorry but this song has to go. Did You Do It? a remix of an already awful track stacked at the end of an album? mad5 I'm sorry but fuck off, M.

Don't Stop - Her first truly awful track. I mean...this sounds like a Tranet song. Madonna, girl.... mad5 

Little Star - Flawless but not better than Has to Be. mad8

Nobody's Perfect - This is an odd song but it has somehow grown on me. I think removing something from this album was the hardest.

X-Static Process - the fact y'all keep chasing the kickass I'm So Stupid over this boring piece of shite. jay1 Suck it, haters!

How High - A filler, and not a good one.

Dance 2night - Always hated this song. Don't know why...I just find it incredibly boring and repetitive. A second duet with JT was also absolutely not necessary.

Superstar, Give Me All Your Luvin' - I don't give a shit. Both of these should have never seen the light of day.

Messiah (Standard), Beautiful Scars (Deluxe) - Both fillers and Bothe incredibly awful.

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
On 4.7.2017 at 7:13 PM, Pandora said:

Rebel Heart - Wash All Over Me (that is a result of the flawless demo?)

Yes and it's flawless! meg1 The demo can rot in hell along with all of Assicii's dated demos!

Link to post
Share on other sites
I Know It - The only acceptable answer. I will cut anyone who even dares to mention anything else! lj1 
Shoo-Bee-Doo - Out of all the fillers (aka. the last three tracks) by far the most unnecessary and dumb one. eve1 
Jimmy Jimmy - I don't mind but I mean...come on. This over some of the better outtakes? wendy4 
Dear Jessie - I love this song and was gonna pick Promise to Try originally but I think if you compare these two DJ is by far the more redundant one.
Waiting - The chorus almost entirely composed from a Justify My Love sample. wendy4 The song itself a total filler on an already overloaded album. The production sounding like a cheap B-movie porn soundtrack. I'm sorry but this song has to go. Did You Do It? a remix of an already awful track stacked at the end of an album? mad5 I'm sorry but fuck off, M.
Don't Stop - Her first truly awful track. I mean...this sounds like a Tranet song. Madonna, girl.... mad5 
Little Star - Flawless but not better than Has to Be. mad8
Nobody's Perfect - This is an odd song but it has somehow grown on me. I think removing something from this album was the hardest.
X-Static Process - the fact y'all keep chasing the kickass I'm So Stupid over this boring piece of shite. jay1 Suck it, haters!
How High - A filler, and not a good one.
Dance 2night - Always hated this song. Don't know why...I just find it incredibly boring and repetitive. A second duet with JT was also absolutely not necessary.
Superstar, Give Me All Your Luvin' - I don't give a shit. Both of these should have never seen the light of day.
Messiah (Standard), Beautiful Scars (Deluxe) - Both fillers and Bothe incredibly awful.
 

I'm So Stupid has aged like wine. I got into it years after buying the album and I use it all the time now.


Posted from my iPhone using the FOTP app
Link to post
Share on other sites

Madonna: Think of Me

Like a Virgin: Shoo-Bee-Doo

True Blue: Jimmy Jimmy

Like a Prayer: Dear Jessie

Erotica: Fever

Bedtime Stories: Don't Stop

Ray of Light: Shanti/Ashtangi

Music: Nothing. Can't touch art

American Life: Die Another Day

Confessions on a Dance Floor: Nothing. Can't touch art

Hard Candy: Incredible

MDNA: Superstar

Rebel Heart: Body Shop

Link to post
Share on other sites

Madonna – Everybody

Like A Virgin  Pretender

True Blue – Love Makes the World Go Round I can't at all ya'll putting Jimmy Jimmy,  you must have quit the album at JJ because you obviously haven't heard the atrocity of LMTWGR.

Like A Prayer – Act of Contrition

I'm Breathless – Something To Remember

Erotica – Words not counting Did You Do It obviously

Bedtime Stories – Don't Stop

Ray of Light – Little Star

Music – Nobody's Perfect 

American Life – American Life creep1

Confessions on a Dancefloor – Push awk1

Hard Candy/MDNA/Rebel Heart – haven't listened to the full albums more than once or twice so can't say.

 

I'm upvoting anyone who puts Love Makes the World Go Round as their choice for TB. Idc if I hate the rest of your choices mad12

Link to post
Share on other sites
16 hours ago, LittleDudeNT5 said:

True Blue – Love Makes the World Go Round I can't at all ya'll putting Jimmy Jimmy,  you must have quit the album at JJ because you obviously haven't heard the atrocity of LMTWGR.

THISS !!! like how do people hate Jimmy Jimmy but love LMTWGR fall2

 

16 hours ago, LittleDudeNT5 said:

Erotica – Words not counting Did You Do It obviously

 

I NEED A REASON WHY YOU HATE THIS SONG !!! rav1

On 7/6/2017 at 4:58 PM, Ursula said:

Waiting - The chorus almost entirely composed from a Justify My Love sample. wendy4 The song itself a total filler on an already overloaded album. The production sounding like a cheap B-movie porn soundtrack. I'm sorry but this song has to go. Did You Do It? a remix of an already awful track stacked at the end of an album? mad5 I'm sorry but fuck off, M.

im not taking up for this awful song and i do understand where you're coming from, but i think that was the type of sound she was going for (new york dark alley, sweaty night club)kylie2

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, DREAMPOP said:

THISS !!! like how do people hate Jimmy Jimmy but love LMTWGR fall2

I NEED A REASON WHY YOU HATE THIS SONG !!! rav1

im not taking up for this awful song and i do understand where you're coming from, but i think that was the type of sound she was going for (new york dark alley, sweaty night club)kylie2

I get that people don't like Jimmy Jimmy – although, personally, I kind of like it in a "filler" type of way. LMTWGR is just boring and annoying.

 

I don't hate it. I actually don't really hate any song on Erotica (Waiting is actually one of my favorites, so I ain't here for the hate for it either mad12) I don't even hate Did You Do It – I find it kind of humorous. I chose Words because out of all the the songs it is my least favorite. The instrumental isn't that good, and her vocals are extremely weak (I get that most of the songs have demo vocals, but she could have at least tired a bit harder). Also I just get tired of it after awhile.

 

Still, I don't necessarily hate it. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Madonna- Think of Me

Like a Virgin- Shoo Bee Doo

True Blue- Jimmy Jimmy

Like a Prayer- Act of Contrition

Erotica- Words

Bedtime Stories- Don't Stop

Ray of Light- Mer Girl

Music- I Deserve It

American Life- X-Static Process

Confessions- Like It or Not (still love it though)

Hard Candy- Spanish Lesson

MDNA- I Don't Give A

Rebel Heart- Bitch I'm Madonna

Link to post
Share on other sites
On 7/5/2017 at 7:39 PM, Satori said:

Bedtime Stories - Inside Of Me

Music - I Deserve It (good song tho emoji20.png)

 

scream1 Wow what a flop bitch ignore her she drinks wtf brit3

Inside of Me is one of my favorites from BS now. The only acceptable answer to which song to remove is Don't Stop. It's one of exactly two songs on the album that feel formulaic compared to how amazing the rest of the album is.

 

And the only song that could feasibly be taken off Music is Nobody's Perfect but it's still a great song.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Replies 50
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic


  • Browsing now   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×