How can Madonna be considered the queen of pop when she is such a bad live performer?

[Simón. 28,789]

19 hours ago, ShutUpRae said:

i can understand why some might think that , Madonna's live performances are not typically highly choreographed and they dont focus on that type of energy like say Janet or Britney's. Madonna has a unique blend of visuals, elegance and minor choreography, sometimes with live vocals or not. She has a different type of performance style that i would say requires a different type of talent. It's almost like watching play

Yes iconic 

Madonna could never!

 

[Simón. 28,789]

8 minutes ago, Salvatore said:

So far, I‘ve seen more barking than biting but do what you have to do.  

*opens NHB thread*

*asks mods to close it*

[Madonna 46,041]

20 minutes ago, petedagrk said:

Yes indeed. ARTPOP is my fave

WOW.  

[Madonna 46,041]

Just now, petedagrk said:

Its not for anyone

The album is a tragedy. An inconsistent MESS full of rejects and songs from other artists that were recycled.

[Frozen 129]

Madonna is a good performer, I will give her that.

[Merryem 8,076]

38 minutes ago, petedagrk said:

Yes indeed. ARTPOP is my fave

talent stan

6 minutes ago, Salvatore said:

The album is a tragedy. An inconsistent MESS full of rejects and songs from other artists that were recycled.

nontalent stan

[Merryem 8,076]

1 hour ago, havok said:

Quality, stellar, legacy. Those are adjectives that don't belong in the same sentence that "Lady Gaga". Stop whining and acting like a child because someone is not as deluded as you to pretend that the fad is anything but a glorified has-been. Downvote me all you want, that fact will never change, xoxo. 

the overreaction  fossils really be on this forum talking about how our posts will never change "the queen of music's status" or some shit and then they really be out here typing paragraphs defending her  the only thing that'll never change is how insufferable fossil and its fans are and the fact that nearly every artist compared to her is infinitely more talented. sad.

[fab 21,653]

10 minutes ago, Salvatore said:

The album is a tragedy. An inconsistent MESS full of rejects and songs from other artists that were recycled.

nawt her rejects STILL being Grammy worthy hits  

[Guest]

13 hours ago, Pennywise said:

Also no other girl could handle S&S, dancing for 2,5 hours, not even Beyonce

Read more about Formation World Tour then lol

Five acts + encore. When will Madonna? Unfortunately, never

[Guest]

1 hour ago, petedagrk said:

Yes indeed. ARTPOP is my fave

Yes we stan GODpop in this house

[Vesper 5,443]

1 hour ago, Simón. said:

Yes iconic 

Madonna could never!

 

 

Yeah Madonna could never.  

[Guest]

2 hours ago, Simón. said:

Yes iconic 

Madonna could never!

 

omg my new fave GIF

[BreatheeOnKnee 480]

2 hours ago, Simón. said:

Yes iconic 

Madonna could never!

 

this would have been cute if it was posted 8 years ago 

she doesn't really do this anymore  but go ahead and try to drag britney i guess

[Brightflower 19,304]

This is still going on? 

[havok 1,971]

4 hours ago, Vesper said:

Yeah Madonna could never.  

So you think she's a better performer than Madonna? 

5 hours ago, Merryem said:

the overreaction  fossils really be on this forum talking about how our posts will never change "the queen of music's status" or some shit and then they really be out here typing paragraphs defending her  the only thing that'll never change is how insufferable fossil and its fans are and the fact that nearly every artist compared to her is infinitely more talented. sad.

The fact that you talked about overreaction and then proceeded to type this whiny mess of a post. Sad indeed and pathetic, anyhow, it won't change the fact that your fave is a glorified has-been that is already over. Let that sink in and keep seething child.  

[Merryem 8,076]

17 minutes ago, havok said:

So you think she's a better performer than Madonna? 

The fact that you talked about overreaction and then proceeded to type this whiny mess of a post. Sad indeed and pathetic, anyhow, it won't change the fact that your fave is a glorified has-been that is already over. Let that sink in and keep seething child.  

aha sure jan. continue pretending you're not seething just like your fave  

[HninSi 430]

Gagz ain't no fad.

[Madonna 46,041]

6 hours ago, petedagrk said:

 

A fad? Bish pleas

 

The decline  It pretty much does prove it.

[Vesper 5,443]

14 hours ago, havok said:

So you think she's a better performer than Madonna?   

No. If you had read the post I was responding to, it was Simon dragging ShutupRae’s comment here:

Spoiler

Madonna's live performances are not typically highly choreographed and they dont focus on that type of energy like say Janet or Britney's.

Simon tried it with the funny FF gif, and I corrected her by showing that ShutupRae’s original comment is true: Madonna could never do the complex, highly choreographed routines that focus on “that type of energy” as Britney or Janet, as evidence by the gif’s highly energetic complex choreographed dance routines, the kind that Madonna has never done before.  

 

Did I say Madonna was a worse performer than Brit? No.  It will bode well for you to actually read and think before responding.  

[SeekingThrill 10,035]

17 minutes ago, Vesper said:

Madonna could never do the complex, highly choreographed routines that focus on “that type of energy” as Britney or Janet, as evidence by the gif’s highly energetic complex choreographed dance routines, the kind that Madonna has never done before.  

I think Britney's and Janet's type of choreography doesn't fit to Madonna's music, but Madonna had energetic dance moments.