Jump to content
fab

How can Madonna be considered the queen of pop when she is such a bad live performer?

Recommended Posts

The greatest pop artists of all time all have phenomenal performance skills and their iconic live performances are one of the main reason why they are considered legends in pop musicoprah14  

 

Except for Madonna julia1  

 

Most of her live performances consist of the studio version of the song getting played and Madonna doing some basic choreography, while her background dancers & fancy costumes are distracting from what would otherwise be comparable to a forgettable American Idol audition katy1  

Can she really be considered as the queen of pop if she is lacking so much in such a crucial department? 

Link to post
Share on other sites
18 minutes ago, LG G6 said:

i'm still shocked that she released this song and music video

 

please someone get her on her meds again ahs1

this is Katy Perry and not Madonna sis katy1 

Link to post
Share on other sites
29 minutes ago, fab said:

The greatest pop artists of all time all have phenomenal performance skills and their iconic live performances are one of the main reason why they are considered legends in pop musicoprah14  

 

Except for Madonna julia1  

 

Most of her live performances consist of the studio version of the song getting played and Madonna doing some basic choreography, while her background dancers & fancy costumes are distracting from what would otherwise be comparable to a forgettable American Idol audition katy1  

Can she really be considered as the queen of pop if she is lacking so much in such a crucial department? 

Agreed. Madonna is completely overrated

Link to post
Share on other sites
27 minutes ago, fab said:

The greatest pop artists of all time all have phenomenal performance skills and their iconic live performances are one of the main reason why they are considered legends in pop musicoprah14  

 

Except for Madonna julia1  

 

Most of her live performances consist of the studio version of the song getting played and Madonna doing some basic choreography, while her background dancers & fancy costumes are distracting from what would otherwise be comparable to a forgettable American Idol audition katy1  

Can she really be considered as the queen of pop if she is lacking so much in such a crucial department? 

In terms of delusion, you are starting to give a certain Mariah fan a run for his money. You literally haven’t even seen most of her live concerts, so please have several seats.

Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, Salvatore said:

In terms of delusion, you are starting to give a certain Mariah fan a run for his money. You literally haven’t even seen most of her live concerts, so please have several seats.

has the average person seen all her live performances? no brit4 

I have seen her biggest and most acclaimed performances and that was sufficient to decide that she's a shitty live performer aretha1 

Link to post
Share on other sites

I think she's a good live performer, at least she used to be good.

"Confessions" tour is one of the best tours of all time in my book, i will give her that. she served a good meal with this one.

She doesn't impress me with her vocals though, i've made that clear on more than one occasion, she won't give you life with her vocals, but this is not a necessity for a good show i guess, other girls like britney and jlo don not need vocals to put on a good show either, so..

 

TO ME, Madonna is a solid 7/10 as a live performer. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
13 minutes ago, fab said:

has the average person seen all her live performances? no brit4 

I have seen her biggest and most acclaimed performances and that was sufficient to decide that she's a shitty live performer aretha1 

Then what does it matter? The average person buying a song or an album is what makes you a big popstar. Michael Jackson's last proper tour was in 1997, did that stop him from being the King of Pop just because he didn't even do shows? mad12 

Pop is just short for "popular music", and Madonna's music was popular for decades. Also, you are NOT coming for live performances with Taylor to back you up jj4jj4jj4 

Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, petedagrk said:

I agree vocals are not the only important factor to put on a good show.  I find entertainment value more important.  Tho good live vocals definitely help make it even better which is why I love Gaga, she serves good vocals and a stellar performance.

That's true.  lj1 

Plus some performers excel in one department and fall flat in another, for example gaga can sing great live for the most part, but she can't really dance and/or follow choreo properly.

like most vocalists (gaga, bey, mariah, etc..) can't really dance, but they excel at singing. Madonna is not an excellent singer, but she can dance and she can put on a good show. Same goes to Janet as well, also ciara, JLO .... and to some degree britney.

Link to post
Share on other sites

 Madonna is a beast as a musical artist, but compared to her peers, she wasn't the greatest live. Couldn't sing as well as some, couldn't really dance as well as some and well...she has visuals at least.

Edited by *Starlight*
Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, BEAUX said:

That's true.  lj1 

Plus some performers excel in one department and fall flat in another, for example gaga can sing great live for the most part, but she can't really dance and/or follow choreo properly.

like most vocalists (gaga, bey, mariah, etc..) can't really dance, but they excel at singing. Madonna is not an excellent singer, but she can dance and she can put on a good show. Same goes to Janet as well, also ciara, JLO .... and to some degree britney.

banned.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 158
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

The greatest pop artists of all time all have phenomenal performance skills and their iconic live performances are one of the main reason why they are considered legends in pop music     Exc

In terms of delusion, you are starting to give a certain Mariah fan a run for his money. You literally haven’t even seen most of her live concerts, so please have several seats.

Watch the Girlie Show tour and then we can talk


  • Browsing now   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×