Jump to content

Archived

This thread has been closed to further replies because it was not updated for 12 months. If you wish to have this thread reinstated, please contact an administrator.

Queen Rachel

Britney vs. Xtina: More Memorable Songs?

More memorable?  

27 members have voted

  1. 1. ...Baby One More Time vs. Genie In A Bottle

    • ...Baby One More Time
      21
    • Genie In A Bottle
      6
  2. 2. Sometimes vs. What a Girl Wants

    • Sometimes
      10
    • What a Girl Wants
      17
  3. 3. (You Drive Me) Crazy vs. I Turn to You

    • (You Drive Me) Crazy
      21
    • I Turn to You
      6
  4. 4. Born to Make You Happy vs. Come On Over Baby (All I Want Is You)

    • Born to Make You Happy
      8
    • Come On Over Baby (All I Want Is You)
      19
  5. 5. I'm a Slave 4 U vs. Dirrty

    • I'm a Slave 4 U
      16
    • Dirrty
      11
  6. 6. Overprotected vs. Beautiful

    • Overprotected
      4
    • Beautiful
      23
  7. 7. I'm Not a Girl, Not Yet a Woman vs. Fighter

    • I'm Not a Girl, Not Yet a Woman
      4
    • Fighter
      23
  8. 8. I Love Rock 'n' Roll vs. Can't Hold Us Down

    • I Love Rock 'n' Roll
      9
    • Can't Hold Us Down
      18
  9. 9. Boys vs. The Voice Within

    • Boys
      13
    • The Voice Within
      14
  10. 10. Gimme More vs. Ain't No Other Man

    • Gimme More
      15
    • Ain't No Other Man
      12
  11. 11. Piece of Me vs. Hurt

    • Piece of Me
      15
    • Hurt
      12
  12. 12. Break the Ice vs. Candyman

    • Break the Ice
      10
    • Candyman
      17
  13. 13. Hold It Against Me vs. Not Myself Tonight

    • Hold It Against Me
      21
    • Not Myself Tonight
      6
  14. 14. Criminal vs. You Lost Me

    • Criminal
      17
    • You Lost Me
      10
  15. 15. Work Bitch vs. Your Body

    • Work Bitch
      19
    • Your Body
      8
  16. 16. Scream & Shout vs. Feel This Moment

    • Scream & Shout (Feat. will.i.am)
      18
    • Feel This Moment (Feat. Pitbull)
      9


Recommended Posts

I can't think of a single memorable song from Xtina besides Beautiful, maybe Your Body because of the computer clicking gif but anyways BOMT alone is more memorable than Xtina's discography! 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Xtina wins by landscape lol. BOMT is a shit song cmon! Btw I was expecting Toxic vs Dirrty xD

 

Here you go:

1. Genie In A Bottle 

2. What A Girl Wants 

3. You Drive Me Crazy

4. Come On Over

5. Dirrty 

6. Beautiful 

7. Fighter

8. Can't Hold Us Down

9. The Voice Within

10. Ain't No Other Man

11. Piece of Me

12. Break the Ice

13. Not Myself Tonight

14. You Lost Me

15. Your Body

16.Feel This Moment

Link to post
Share on other sites
22 minutes ago, StrippedX said:

I'm still unbiased, it's just the truth kylie2 

Hmm let's see kylie2 

1. BOMT wins, GIAB is iconic but BOMT & the MV have just become a pop staple 

2. What a girl wants, although I'm coming from an American perspective and a lot of brits early singles didn't do too hot here 

3. YDMC

4. #1 underrated bop Come On Over 

5. I would say S4U because of just how much of a massive flop Dirrty seemed to be here, but WW it might be Dirrty so we'll call it a tie kylie2 

6. Beautiful, no doubt

7. Fighter probably

8. Can't Hold Us Down

9. Idk they're both forgotten

10. Gimme More "It's Britney bitch" jj2 

11. Piece of Me

12. Candyman 

13. Hold It Against Me

14. Both flops

15. Work Bitch

16. Both pretty big hits but I'd say scream & shout was bigger 

 

B: 7 X: 6 Tie: 3 

 

But I doubt you're American so I'd be curious as to what your choices were jj2 

Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, Jae said:

Hmm let's see kylie2 

1. BOMT wins, GIAB is iconic but BOMT & the MV have just become a pop staple 

2. What a girl wants, although I'm coming from an American perspective and a lot of brits early singles didn't do too hot here 

3. YDMC

4. #1 underrated bop Come On Over 

5. I would say S4U because of just how much of a massive flop Dirrty seemed to be here, but WW it might be Dirrty so we'll call it a tie kylie2 

6. Beautiful, no doubt

7. Fighter probably

8. Can't Hold Us Down

9. Idk they're both forgotten

10. Gimme More "It's Britney bitch" jj2 

11. Piece of Me

12. Candyman 

13. Hold It Against Me

14. Both flops

15. Work Bitch

16. Both pretty big hits but I'd say scream & shout was bigger 

 

B: 7 X: 6 Tie: 3 

 

But I doubt you're American so I'd be curious as to what your choices were jj2 

I'm European jj2 

1. BOMT does win, even though both were huge.

2. What A Girl Wants by MILES.

3. I Turn To You, it has a bigger nostalgia factor.

4. Come On Over, like all Christina's debut singles, was HUGE.

5. I get that Dirrty failed to chart high in America, but it's still ICONIC and charted well worldwide. So, for me, that song wins since it's more talked about than Slave jj2 

6. Beautiful, signature song.

7. Fighter.

8. Actually, I put I Love Rock N Roll here. Maybe it's just here in my country, but CHUD didn't do anything here. 

9. The Voice Within TO BE HONEST. I didn't hear Boys until just a few years ago kii1 

10. I put Ain't No Other Man, but I guess the "It's Britney, bitch!" makes hers more memoarble.

11. Hurt omg.

12. Candyman.

13. Hold It Against Me (NMT on the internet though lol)

14. None smh. YLM so underrated. 

15. Work Bitch

16. Feel This Moment because of the sample.

So.

Tie: 1 Brit: 5 X: 10 

Guess X slayed harder than I thought kylie2 

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, StrippedX said:

How are yall gonna say Slave is more memorable than Dirrty? Maybe locally but child... Dirrty is ICONIC clap1 Even in 2018, it's talked about and featured in social media memes. Go home.

 

Looks like as Iconic as Dirrrty is (it’s a bop), it’s not as remembered as you think... xtina2

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

1. BOMT BY MILES. 

2. What A Girl Wants - one of my fav Xtina tracks

3. You Drive Me Crazy - Melissa Joan Hart even starred in the video brit0 

4. Come On Over - another great Xtina track

5. Slave 4 U - as iconic as Dirrty is, it’s not as remembered. I go clubbing quite often and I’ve heard Slave at least twice recently, and dirrrty not a single time. And the teens react video doesn’t lie. brit10 

6. Beautiful - duh

7. Fighter - one of my least favorite Xtina tracks that was actually liked by the majority. But better than INAG.

8. I Love Rock N Roll

9. Boys - featured in Austin Powers, people will remember the robo titties (in b4 robotney jokes brit2)

10. It’s Britney Bitch!

11. Piece of Me - won a VMA :)

12. Candyman.

13. Hold It Against Me #1 bitches!

14. Neither brit4 

15. Work Bitch

16. Scream and Shout

So.

Tie: 1 Brit: 10 X: 5

 

PS this list is kind of bogus as it leaves out a lot of Britney’s most memorable songs...and since britney has 2x the discog as Xtina it shouldn’t be surprising that her songs are more remembered... like where’s:

Oops I did it again

Stronger

Lucky

Me Against The Music

Everytime

TOXIC? mad4 Her signature song?

Womanizer

Circus

Till The World Ends

I Wanna Go...

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, StrippedX said:

I'm European jj2 

1. BOMT does win, even though both were huge.

2. What A Girl Wants by MILES.

3. I Turn To You, it has a bigger nostalgia factor.

4. Come On Over, like all Christina's debut singles, was HUGE.

5. I get that Dirrty failed to chart high in America, but it's still ICONIC and charted well worldwide. So, for me, that song wins since it's more talked about than Slave jj2 

6. Beautiful, signature song.

7. Fighter.

8. Actually, I put I Love Rock N Roll here. Maybe it's just here in my country, but CHUD didn't do anything here. 

9. The Voice Within TO BE HONEST. I didn't hear Boys until just a few years ago kii1 

10. I put Ain't No Other Man, but I guess the "It's Britney, bitch!" makes hers more memoarble.

11. Hurt omg.

12. Candyman.

13. Hold It Against Me (NMT on the internet though lol)

14. None smh. YLM so underrated. 

15. Work Bitch

16. Feel This Moment because of the sample.

So.

Tie: 1 Brit: 5 X: 10 

Guess X slayed harder than I thought kylie2 

I'm just gonna have to agree to disagree on some of these.. choices kylie2 

24 minutes ago, Vesper said:

 

Looks like as Iconic as Dirrrty is (it’s a bop), it’s not as remembered as you think... xtina2

 

The reactions when OIDIA started playing alone oprah14 

Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, ParentalAdvisory said:

wat2 which one

Like What A Girl Wants um2 I Turn To You um2 etc

I don't think I even know how they sound like lol. Britney is losing here only few times (with Dirrty, Beautiful, Fighter, The Voice Within, Ain't No Other Man - but lbr when compared to Gimme More... I'd give it a tie ok - and Candyman). Let me remind you that we talk about more memorable songs (NMT, You Lost Me and Your Body are better songs f.e. but they are not more memorable).

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 39
  • Created
  • Last Reply

  • Browsing now   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×