What if all the FOTP faves had their peak moment at the same time?

[Shego 36,847]

Let's pretend we are in 2018 and all the FOTP faves are at the same age, and they are at their biggest and most glorious days of their career

Let's imagine:

• Madonna was at her True Blue/Like a Prayer/The Immaculate Collection days
• Mariah at her Self Titled/Music Box/Daydream days
• Britney Spears at her ...Baby One More Time/Oops! ...I Did It Again/Britney days
• Beyonce at her 4/Self Titled/Lemonade days
• Christina Aguilera at her Stripped/Back To Basic days
• Rihanna at her Good Girl Gone Bad/Rated R/Loud days
• Lady Gaga at her The Fame/Born This Way days
• Katy Perry at her One Of The Boys/Teenage Dream/Prism days
• Taylor Swift at her Red/1989/Reputation days

 

Who do you think would have been:

• The most successful:
• The less successful:
• The most admired:
• The most loved:
• The most hated:
• The biggest fashion icon:
• With the biggest impact on music:
• With the biggest stan base:
• The most controversial:
• The most ambitious
• The most daring:
• The most fearless:

etc.

Also I really wanna see who do you think would have the biggest Spotify, YouTube numbers

Rank them

I didn't count the rest FOTP faves cause their success wasn't that big yet

Even if Lana could easily outsold all the faves combined if she was at the 70's

 

 

[Galactic-Tiger 12,095]

Madonna for All 

[Mariah's 19 #1s 1,281]

Beitney and Mariah had the biggest peaks so they’d demolish everyone

[Shego 36,847]

22 minutes ago, The One Above All said:

Madonna for All 

 

16 minutes ago, Anna Wintour said:

Beitney and Mariah had the biggest peaks so they’d demolish everyone

I added this for a reason

• The most successful:
• The less successful:
• The most admired:
• The most loved:
• The most hated:
• The biggest fashion icon:
• With the biggest impact on music:
• With the biggest stan base:
• The most controversial:
• The most ambitious
• The most daring:
• The most fearless:

 

[Michael. 41,147]

The most successful, loved and admired would be Mariah because she would be that cute girl with a big voice who sings ballads among all those controversial girls, the gp darling  

The least successful would be Beyoncé.  

[LÉON 20,857]

Not you picking 4/Beyonce/Lemonade as ha peak  

[CalixSpurius 2,386]

• The most successful: Madonna
• The less successful: (I don't care)
• The most admired: Madonna
• The most loved: Beyoncé
• The most hated: (I don't care)
• The biggest fashion icon: Madonna & Lady Gaga
• With the biggest impact on music: Madonna
• With the biggest stan base: Lady Gaga
• The most controversial: Madonna
• The most ambitious: (I don't know)
• The most daring: Madonna & Lady Gaga
• The most fearless: Madonna

[Galactic-Tiger 12,095]

• The most successful: Madonna
• The less successful: Taylor Swift
• The most admired: Madonna
• The most loved: Madonna
• The most hated: Madonna
• The biggest fashion icon: Madonna
• With the biggest impact on music: Madonna
• With the biggest stan base: Madonna
• The most controversial: Madonna
• The most ambitious: Madonna
• The most daring: Madonna 
• The most fearless: Madonna    

[Shego 36,847]

24 minutes ago, Modern Woman said:

Not you picking 4/Beyonce/Lemonade as ha peak  

Musically it was + people were praising her more than ever

[Galactic-Tiger 12,095]

Edited. 

[Princess Aurora 31,346]

I'd be probably bald If pop girl were as successful as they were back then nowadays  

[P.O.P 6,000]

Kylie would end them all with Fever

 

[Cloud-Ninetales 4,761]

15 minutes ago, P.O.P said:

Kylie would end them all with Fever

 

Not in America  

[Vulnicura. 7,258]

Doesn't magnum opus mean that the work has to be both critically well received and considered as the artist's best work? By that definition some of these albums are the wrong choices. Popular ≠ Magnum Opus

[Shego 36,847]

9 minutes ago, Vulnicura. said:

Doesn't magnum opus mean that the work has to be both critically well received and considered as the artist's best work? By that definition some of these albums are the wrong choices. Popular ≠ Magnum Opus

Ok that was just to for the title, to not be bigger

[Tomás 23,320]

the DELUSION in madonna's stanbase skksksk i have to laugh

[H.O.N.E.Y 11,164]

@Tomás no lies told. 

[H.O.N.E.Y 11,164]

• The most successful: Britney & Riri
• The less successful: Bey
• The most admired: Christina
• The most loved: Gaga
• The most hated: Madonna
• The biggest fashion icon: Christina
• With the biggest impact on music: Mariah
• With the biggest stan base: Gaga
• The most controversial: Madonna
• The most ambitious: Christina
• The most daring: Christina
• The most fearless: Christina

[Shego 36,847]

12 minutes ago, H.O.N.E.Y said:

@Tomás no lies told. 

[P.E.T.E.R. 8,353]

• The most successful: Madonna or Mariah
• The less successful: prolly Katy or Taylor
• The most admired: Mariah
• The most loved: Britney or Katy
• The most hated:
• The biggest fashion icon: Madonna
• With the biggest impact on music:
• With the biggest stan base: Gaga
• The most controversial: Madonna or Gaga
• The most ambitious: Gaga
• The most daring: Madonna
• The most fearless: Christina