Jump to content

Archived

This thread has been closed to further replies because it was not updated for 12 months. If you wish to have this thread reinstated, please contact an administrator.

Katy Petty

Was Christina ever the “it” girl?

Recommended Posts

Well critically and hit wise xtina was the it pop girl 1999-2001, or one of the it girls atleast. She was successfully touring, had a successful album, 4 no. 1 singles, fashion icon, vocal prodigy etc. 

Even when she went dirty she was an IT girl. Every night out I go on you hear dirty in some capacity. 

Her commercial decline doesn't reflect on her peak which was brilliant tbh

Link to post
Share on other sites

When it comes to popularity Britney was the Ariana in that they both got bigger until they peaked and went from girl next door to queens while Xtina was the Demi...

Link to post
Share on other sites
12 minutes ago, I Brings That Levity said:

When it comes to popularity Britney was the Ariana in that they both got bigger until they peaked and went from girl next door to queens while Xtina was the Demi...

Ariana and Demi don't have any correlation tho; comparing Britney to Selena would be a more accurate assessment

Link to post
Share on other sites
8 minutes ago, Venom said:

Ariana and Demi don't have any correlation tho; comparing Britney to Selena would be a more accurate assessment

But Britney and Ariana had impact. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, I Brings That Levity said:

But Britney and Ariana had impact. 

But Britney and Selena sold the best out of their groups + started on Disney Channel alongside Xtina and Demi + whisper live + have mental health problems + relatively disappeared after their mid 2010s albums that are considered the peaks of their creative control

Link to post
Share on other sites

Briefly in 2003 when she was practically flopping and embarrassing herself with her spray tanned slut persona in dirtty while Britney was making  one of the most iconic pop albums of the decade . Then ITZ was released near the end of 2003, she's never been close to that amount of relevancy ever since

Link to post
Share on other sites
31 minutes ago, ShutUpRae said:

Briefly in 2003 when she was practically flopping and embarrassing herself with her spray tanned slut persona in dirtty while Britney was making  one of the most iconic pop albums of the decade . Then ITZ was released near the end of 2003, she's never been close to that amount of relevancy ever since

She was the top female artist of 2003, “Stripped” outsold ITZ hunty bey4 

Im pretty sure it was Britney that embarrassed herself when she cancelled her tour, And was spotted walking out of gas stations barefoot with Cheeto stains on her face circa 2004.

Also, Christina was the it girl in the year 2000. When she beat Britney at the Grammys, had 3 #1 singles off her debut CD and was also named the top female artist

that year as well. nat1  

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Emperor Nick said:

Well critically and hit wise xtina was the it pop girl 1999-2001, or one of the it girls atleast. She was successfully touring, had a successful album, 4 no. 1 singles, fashion icon, vocal prodigy etc. 

Even when she went dirty she was an IT girl. Every night out I go on you hear dirty in some capacity. 

Her commercial decline doesn't reflect on her peak which was brilliant tbh

Britney’s commercial decline was a lot more drastic than Xtina’s.

Britney 

1999-BOMT-13x platinum 

2000-Oops-10x platinum

2001-Britney 4x platinum

I mean if anyone declined in those years it was definetly Britney over Xtina after their debut albums. The “Britney” era sold a lot less and made no significant impact with its singles. When Xtina dropped “Stripped,” a year later, she was definetly more relevant than Britney during the year that followed. “Stripped” outsold ITZ and even “Back to Basics” outsold Blackout in 2006-2007, so this notion that Xtina was always second is nothing but fiction created by deluded Britney fans. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Cl!t said:

Out of all the faves she just seems to be on the bottom of the bracket. And she had her moment next to Britney who is undoubtedly the bigger star and overshadowed her. xtina2 

She's pretty much like the Katy Perry of her pack (well not exactly since Christina actually sings) a huge debut album, and amazing second one (not counting the platinum Xmas album and the multiplatinum spanish record) a thrid solid double grammy award winning record a multicertified greatest hits record in 2008 and then Bionic... well wait, no, she's nothing like Katy she had a tope ten hit 15 years after her debut...I think Katy is at the bottom of the bracket right now, no voice, no grammys no new hits... Thanks

Link to post
Share on other sites

Xtina did have a big heyday during CA and Stripped, and even B2B was very successful. She’s fallen hard off the radar since but most of the 2000s pop girls are flops or not making music anymore anyway. brit2 

Link to post
Share on other sites
13 minutes ago, Vesper said:

Xtina did have a big heyday during CA and Stripped, and even B2B was very successful. She’s fallen hard off the radar since but most of the 2000s pop girls are flops or not making music anymore anyway. brit2 

Not like any of the 2010 girls are any better. Unfortunately Taylor Swift will be the Top Female artist of the decade and she’s technically a 00’s girl. brit2

Link to post
Share on other sites

She was considered one in the past, but she's now currently the worst performing fave on this site. Can't even chart with loads of promotion. Imagine doing worse than Kesha who's stuck in some horrible shit.  dead2 

Link to post
Share on other sites
7 minutes ago, Jake said:

She was considered one in the past, but she's now currently the worst performing fave on this site. Can't even chart with loads of promotion. Imagine doing worse than Kesha who's stuck in some horrible shit.  dead2 

And what promotion is that exactly? brit8 

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Mistress 9 said:

She's pretty much like the Katy Perry of her pack (well not exactly since Christina actually sings) a huge debut album, and amazing second one (not counting the platinum Xmas album and the multiplatinum spanish record) a thrid solid double grammy award winning record a multicertified greatest hits record in 2008 and then Bionic... well wait, no, she's nothing like Katy she had a tope ten hit 15 years after her debut...I think Katy is at the bottom of the bracket right now, no voice, no grammys no new hits... Thanks

Didn’t Never Really Over outpeak anything Christina has tried recently? gaga6

 

And moo12

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 68
  • Created
  • Last Reply

  • Browsing now   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×