Jump to content

Archived

This thread has been closed to further replies because it was not updated for 12 months. If you wish to have this thread reinstated, please contact an administrator.

GAGA

Mariah Carey vs Whitney Houston

Recommended Posts

Bold the option you prefer and tally up the results to see which artist won. 

TRY not to be biased.
 

MARIAH CAREY vs WHITNEY HOUSTON

moo5  whit2

 

FIRST NO. 1 ON BILLBOARD:

Vision Of Love / Saving All My Love

THIRD SONG TO GO NO. 1 ON HOT R&B:

Emotions / Greatest Love Of All

EARLY 90s POWER BALLAD:

Hero / I Will Always Love You

PEAKED AT NO. 4 ON BILLBOARD:

I Still Believe / I’m Every Woman 

SONG WITH "HEARTBREAK" IN TITLE:

Heartbreaker / Heartbreak Hotel

2002 LEAD SINGLE FLOP:

Through The Rain / Whatchulookinat 

LATE 90s SMASH HIT:

Honey / It’s Not Right But It’s Okay

PEAKED AT NO. 3 IN UK:

Always Be My Baby / I Have Nothing

SEVENTH NO. 1 ON BILLBOARD:

Dreamlover / Where Do Broken Hearts Go

COVER SONG:

I’ll Be There / Higher Love

LATE 90s BALLAD: 

My All / I Believe In You And Me

MARIAH:

WHITNEY: 

Link to post
Share on other sites

FIRST NO. 1 ON BILLBOARD:

Vision Of Love / Saving All My Love

THIRD SONG TO GO NO. 1:

Emotions / Greatest Love Of All

EARLY 90s POWER BALLAD:

Hero / I Will Always Love You

PEAKED AT NO. 4 ON BILLBOARD:

I Still Believe / I’m Every Woman 

SONG WITH "HEARTBREAK" IN TITLE:

Heartbreaker / Heartbreak Hotel

2002 LEAD SINGLE FLOP:

Through The Rain / Whatchulookinat 

LATE 90s SMASH HIT:

Honey / It’s Not Right But It’s Okay

PEAKED AT NO. 3 IN UK:

Always Be My Baby / I Have Nothing

SEVENTH NO. 1 ON BILLBOARD:

Dreamlover / Where Do Broken Hearts Go

COVER SONG:

I’ll Be There / Higher Love

1998 BALLAD: 

My All / I Believe In You And Me

MARIAH: 4

WHITNEY: 2

 

Picked the songs i only knew. nicki5 

Link to post
Share on other sites

FIRST NO. 1 ON BILLBOARD:

Vision Of Love / Saving All My Love

THIRD SONG TO GO NO. 1:

Emotions / Greatest Love Of All

EARLY 90s POWER BALLAD:

Hero / I Will Always Love You

PEAKED AT NO. 4 ON BILLBOARD:

I Still Believe / I’m Every Woman 

SONG WITH "HEARTBREAK" IN TITLE:

Heartbreaker / Heartbreak Hotel

2002 LEAD SINGLE FLOP:

Through The Rain / Whatchulookinat 

LATE 90s SMASH HIT:

Honey / It’s Not Right But It’s Okay

PEAKED AT NO. 3 IN UK:

Always Be My Baby / I Have Nothing

SEVENTH NO. 1 ON BILLBOARD:

Dreamlover / Where Do Broken Hearts Go

COVER SONG:

I’ll Be There / Higher Love

1998 BALLAD: 

My All / I Believe In You And Me

MARIAH: 3

WHITNEY: 8

 

Moo's whisper vocals have no chance hottie1

Link to post
Share on other sites

FIRST NO. 1 ON BILLBOARD:

Vision Of Love / Saving All My Love

THIRD SONG TO GO NO. 1:

Emotions / Greatest Love Of All

EARLY 90s POWER BALLAD:

Hero / I Will Always Love You

PEAKED AT NO. 4 ON BILLBOARD:

I Still Believe / I’m Every Woman 

SONG WITH "HEARTBREAK" IN TITLE:

Heartbreaker / Heartbreak Hotel

2002 LEAD SINGLE FLOP:

Through The Rain / Whatchulookinat 

LATE 90s SMASH HIT:

Honey / It’s Not Right But It’s Okay

PEAKED AT NO. 3 IN UK:

Always Be My Baby / I Have Nothing

SEVENTH NO. 1 ON BILLBOARD:

Dreamlover / Where Do Broken Hearts Go

COVER SONG:

I’ll Be There / Higher Love

1998 BALLAD: 

My All / I Believe In You And Me

MARIAH: 7

WHITNEY: 4


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

FIRST NO. 1 ON BILLBOARD:

Vision Of Love / Saving All My Love

THIRD SONG TO GO NO. 1:

Emotions / Greatest Love Of All

EARLY 90s POWER BALLAD:

Hero / I Will Always Love You

PEAKED AT NO. 4 ON BILLBOARD:

I Still Believe / I’m Every Woman 

SONG WITH "HEARTBREAK" IN TITLE:

Heartbreaker / Heartbreak Hotel

2002 LEAD SINGLE FLOP:

Through The Rain / Whatchulookinat 

LATE 90s SMASH HIT:

Honey / It’s Not Right But It’s Okay

PEAKED AT NO. 3 IN UK:

Always Be My Baby / I Have Nothing

SEVENTH NO. 1 ON BILLBOARD:

Dreamlover / Where Do Broken Hearts Go

COVER SONG:

I’ll Be There / Higher Love

1998 BALLAD: 

My All / I Believe In You And Me

MARIAH:   7

WHITNEY: 4

Link to post
Share on other sites

FIRST NO. 1 ON BILLBOARD:

Vision Of Love / Saving All My Love

THIRD SONG TO GO NO. 1:

Emotions / Greatest Love Of All

EARLY 90s POWER BALLAD:

Hero / I Will Always Love You

PEAKED AT NO. 4 ON BILLBOARD:

I Still Believe / I’m Every Woman 

SONG WITH "HEARTBREAK" IN TITLE:

Heartbreaker / Heartbreak Hotel

2002 LEAD SINGLE FLOP:

Through The Rain / Whatchulookinat 

LATE 90s SMASH HIT:

Honey / It’s Not Right But It’s Okay

PEAKED AT NO. 3 IN UK:

Always Be My Baby / I Have Nothing

SEVENTH NO. 1 ON BILLBOARD:

Dreamlover / Where Do Broken Hearts Go

COVER SONG:

I’ll Be There / Higher Love

1998 BALLAD: 

My All / I Believe In You And Me

MARIAH: 9

WHITNEY: 2 

Link to post
Share on other sites

FIRST NO. 1 ON BILLBOARD:

Vision Of Love / Saving All My Love

THIRD SONG TO GO NO. 1:

Emotions / Greatest Love Of All

EARLY 90s POWER BALLAD:

Hero / I Will Always Love You

PEAKED AT NO. 4 ON BILLBOARD:

I Still Believe / I’m Every Woman 

SONG WITH "HEARTBREAK" IN TITLE:

Heartbreaker / Heartbreak Hotel

2002 LEAD SINGLE FLOP:

Through The Rain / Whatchulookinat 

LATE 90s SMASH HIT:

Honey / It’s Not Right But It’s Okay

PEAKED AT NO. 3 IN UK:

Always Be My Baby / I Have Nothing

SEVENTH NO. 1 ON BILLBOARD:

Dreamlover / Where Do Broken Hearts Go

COVER SONG:

I’ll Be There / Higher Love

1998 BALLAD: 

My All / I Believe In You And Me

MARIAH: 8

WHITNEY: 3

 
Link to post
Share on other sites

MARIAH CAREY vs WHITNEY HOUSTON

moo5  whit2

 

FIRST NO. 1 ON BILLBOARD:

Vision Of Love / Saving All My Love

THIRD SONG TO GO NO. 1:

Emotions / Greatest Love Of All

EARLY 90s POWER BALLAD:

Hero / I Will Always Love You

PEAKED AT NO. 4 ON BILLBOARD:

I Still Believe / I’m Every Woman 

SONG WITH "HEARTBREAK" IN TITLE:

Heartbreaker / Heartbreak Hotel

2002 LEAD SINGLE FLOP:

Through The Rain / Whatchulookinat 

LATE 90s SMASH HIT:

Honey / It’s Not Right But It’s Okay

PEAKED AT NO. 3 IN UK:

Always Be My Baby / I Have Nothing

SEVENTH NO. 1 ON BILLBOARD:

Dreamlover / Where Do Broken Hearts Go

COVER SONG:

I’ll Be There / Higher Love

1998 BALLAD: 

My All / I Believe In You And Me

MARIAH: 6

WHITNEY: 5

Someday was Mariah's third number one, not Emotions. Also, I Believe in You and Me was a hit in 1997.

 
Link to post
Share on other sites
11 minutes ago, CharnyBoy said:

Someday was Mariah's third number one, not Emotions. Also, I Believe in You and Me was a hit in 1997.

 

Thanks for the corrections! I Must’ve gotten things mixed up when I was researching categories to make for it. I changed the "3rd no. 1" category to better fit the options and changed the 1998 ballad category to "late 90’s ballad" gag1

Link to post
Share on other sites

FIRST NO. 1 ON BILLBOARD:

Vision of Love / Saving All My Love

 

THIRD SONG TO GO NO. 1 ON HOT R&B:

Emotions / Greatest Love Of All

 

EARLY 90s POWER BALLAD:

Hero / I Will Always Love You

 

PEAKED AT NO. 4 ON BILLBOARD:

I Still Believe / I’m Every Woman

 

SONG WITH “HEARTBREAK” IN TITLE:

Heartbreaker / Heartbreak Hotel

 

2002 LEAD SINGLE FLOP: 

Through the Rain / Whatchulookinat

 

LATE 90s SMASH HIT:

Honey / It’s Not Right But It’s Okay

 

PEAKED AT NO. 3 IN UK:

Always Be My Baby / I Have Nothing

 

SEVENTH NO. 1 ON BILLBOARD:

Dreamlover / Where Do Broken Hearts Go

 

COVER SONG:

I’ll Be There / Higher Love

 

LATE 90s BALLAD:

My All / I Believe In You And Me

 

MARIAH: 9

WHITNEY: 4

 

 

We live for Whitney, though!

12l5.gif

Link to post
Share on other sites

FIRST NO. 1 ON BILLBOARD:

Vision Of Love / Saving All My Love

THIRD SONG TO GO NO. 1 ON HOT R&B:

Emotions / Greatest Love Of All

EARLY 90s POWER BALLAD:

Hero / I Will Always Love You

PEAKED AT NO. 4 ON BILLBOARD:

I Still Believe / I’m Every Woman 

SONG WITH "HEARTBREAK" IN TITLE:

Heartbreaker / Heartbreak Hotel

2002 LEAD SINGLE FLOP:

Through The Rain / Whatchulookinat 

LATE 90s SMASH HIT:

Honey / It’s Not Right But It’s Okay

PEAKED AT NO. 3 IN UK:

Always Be My Baby / I Have Nothing

SEVENTH NO. 1 ON BILLBOARD:

Dreamlover / Where Do Broken Hearts Go

COVER SONG:

I’ll Be There / Higher Love

LATE 90s BALLAD: 

My All / I Believe In You And Me

MARIAH: 7

WHITNEY: 4

Link to post
Share on other sites

MARIAH CAREY vs WHITNEY HOUSTON

moo5  whit2

 

FIRST NO. 1 ON BILLBOARD:

Vision Of Love / Saving All My Love

THIRD SONG TO GO NO. 1 ON HOT R&B:

Emotions / Greatest Love Of All

EARLY 90s POWER BALLAD:

Hero / I Will Always Love You

PEAKED AT NO. 4 ON BILLBOARD:

I Still Believe / I’m Every Woman 

SONG WITH "HEARTBREAK" IN TITLE:

Heartbreaker / Heartbreak Hotel

2002 LEAD SINGLE FLOP:

Through The Rain / Whatchulookinat 

LATE 90s SMASH HIT:

Honey / It’s Not Right But It’s Okay

PEAKED AT NO. 3 IN UK:

Always Be My Baby / I Have Nothing

SEVENTH NO. 1 ON BILLBOARD:

Dreamlover / Where Do Broken Hearts Go

COVER SONG:

I’ll Be There / Higher Love

LATE 90s BALLAD: 

My All / I Believe In You And Me

MARIAH: 6 (8 with tie)

WHITNEY: 5 (7 with tie)

 

WHY WAS THIS THE HARDEST ONE WTFgiveup3

I had another tie but I really needed to think and not have ANOTHER tie.

I love both of them and miss Whitney so much

Link to post
Share on other sites
24 minutes ago, Billie Frank said:

It's a shame Mariah and Whitney never done more songs together. Their chemistry was so special and their voices blended perfectly. 

 

 

Whew cry7


the actual cultural shift that took place when their voices blended fall7

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

MARIAH CAREY vs WHITNEY HOUSTON

moo5  whit2

 

FIRST NO. 1 ON BILLBOARD:

Vision Of Love / Saving All My Love

THIRD SONG TO GO NO. 1 ON HOT R&B:

Emotions / Greatest Love Of All

EARLY 90s POWER BALLAD:

Hero / I Will Always Love You

PEAKED AT NO. 4 ON BILLBOARD:

I Still Believe / I’m Every Woman 

SONG WITH "HEARTBREAK" IN TITLE:

Heartbreaker / Heartbreak Hotel

2002 LEAD SINGLE FLOP:

Through The Rain / Whatchulookinat 

LATE 90s SMASH HIT:

Honey / It’s Not Right But It’s Okay

PEAKED AT NO. 3 IN UK:

Always Be My Baby / I Have Nothing

SEVENTH NO. 1 ON BILLBOARD:

Dreamlover / Where Do Broken Hearts Go

COVER SONG:

I’ll Be There / Higher Love

LATE 90s BALLAD: 

My All / I Believe In You And Me

MARIAH: 7

WHITNEY: 4

Link to post
Share on other sites

FIRST NO. 1 ON BILLBOARD:

Vision Of Love / Saving All My Love

THIRD SONG TO GO NO. 1 ON HOT R&B:

Emotions / Greatest Love Of All

EARLY 90s POWER BALLAD:

Hero / I Will Always Love You

PEAKED AT NO. 4 ON BILLBOARD:

I Still Believe / I’m Every Woman 

SONG WITH "HEARTBREAK" IN TITLE:

Heartbreaker / Heartbreak Hotel

2002 LEAD SINGLE FLOP:

Through The Rain / Whatchulookinat 

LATE 90s SMASH HIT:

Honey / It’s Not Right But It’s Okay

PEAKED AT NO. 3 IN UK:

Always Be My Baby / I Have Nothing

SEVENTH NO. 1 ON BILLBOARD:

Dreamlover / Where Do Broken Hearts Go

COVER SONG:

I’ll Be There / Higher Love

LATE 90s BALLAD: 

My All / I Believe In You And Me

MARIAH: 11

WHITNEY: 5

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 24
  • Created
  • Last Reply

  • Browsing now   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×