Best singer in the Vocal Trinity

[Lynk 10,991]

Whitney Houston, Mariah Carey and Celine Dion are three of the biggest artists to grace the music industry. Known for their powerhouse vocals, they have labelled "The Vocal Trinity". But of the three, which of the following is the best vocalist of the three? Base your decision on the following:

• Power
• Range
• Control
• Tone
• Overall Vocal Talent

[jrdn 26,669]

• Power: Whitney
• Range: Mariah
• Control: Celine or Mariah (it depends how you look at it, Celine has a better head voice but Mariahs low range is far better)
• Tone: Mariah (tone is personal preference)
• Overall Vocal Talent: All 3 are equally talented vocally in my eyes. 

 

"Insert the usual moronic comments from certain well known users shading Mariah for the sake of it instead of enjoying all 3 for what they bring". 

[Luca 54,940]

imo Whitney has the best voice in what she does, Mariah has more diversity in her voice, idk Celine's voice well enough to "judge" that. 

[Teenage Wet Dream 2,909]

Whitney has the best voice but let me go by category:

• Power - Whitney
• Range - Mariah
• Control - Celine
• Tone - Whitney
• Overall Vocal Talent - Whitney

[Mikey Likey 2,216]

I’d say Whitney but of the two still alive I’d say Celine due to the fact she has taken care of her voice. 

[Shawn's Slave 19,523]

Whitney. 

 

[Ex 61]

15 minutes ago, Teenage Wet Dream said:

 

• Power - Whitney
• Range - Mariah
• Control - Celine
• Tone - Whitney
• Overall Vocal Talent - Whitney

diz 

[Mario Spears 5,235]

all amazing singer but MARIAH IS THE BEST

[Guest]

Whitney > Mariah > Celine

[Tomás 23,320]

Mariah > Whitney >>> Celine

 

[Chris 58,351]

i dont know any Whitney songs except for the 2 everyone knows and ive never heard a Celine song outside Titanic  

[jrdn 26,669]

19 minutes ago, Chris Morlock said:

i dont know any Whitney songs except for the 2 everyone knows and ive never heard a Celine song outside Titanic  

Whitney has some great stuff, Celine can be hit or miss, most of her music post Titanic is really generic and most of it before Titanic is your usual pop ballad. 

 

These were serves:

 

[Chris 58,351]

2 minutes ago, Billie Frank said:

Whitney has some great stuff, Celine can be hit or miss, most of her music post Titanic is really generic and most of it before Titanic is your usual pop ballad. 

 

These were serves:

 

ill save these for later, thx~

[Gilly 12,318]

mariah and whitney

 

 

 

[Strobo 2,308]

37 minutes ago, Chris Morlock said:

i dont know any Whitney songs except for the 2 everyone knows and ive never heard a Celine song outside Titanic  

I see you got covered with Whitney so here's a bit of Céline! The first two are some of her most well known songs (well, covers) in English, but her best work imo is in French which the other two are examples of.

 

[Miss Show Business 1,200]

Whitney.

Reasons below

Spoiler

 

Of the vocal trinity, I was probably most familiar with Celine at first, but then got into Mariah. Mariah's range is her biggest strong suit, imo. I feel with Mariah, she's an amazing singer, but I feel her vocal technique (singing with vocal chord polyps) has led to a decline in the quality of her voice. In my opinion at least, her strongest vocals were on her debut, and they seemed to slightly decline with each album and turn into the more soft, whispery tone we're familiar with today. She can still sing the hell out of her songs no doubt, and she's the ONLY singer who can sing some of her songs because of her range. Celine is so talented, but I feel her career was kind of riding the coat tails of Mariah and Whitney's. Mariah and Whitney both had other talents outside of just singing, Mariah's writing and lyricism, and Whitney had some success with movies. Celine always just had her voice it seems. Celine's selling point was being born in Quebec, and later building her career up to such great international heights.

Whitney. From the start, her voice was renowned. Her deep, rich, powerful voice is one of a kind, truly. She really is one of the greatest female voices of the 20th century, rivalling maybe ONLY the great Barbra Streisand and Aretha Franklin. Whitney's tragedy of course was her untimely death and her addictions which likely led to her vocal decline at that end of her career. Still, I feel it's nearly impossible to top Whitney in her prime.

 

 

[jrdn 26,669]

1 hour ago, Strobo said:

I see you got covered with Whitney so here's a bit of Céline! The first two are some of her most well known songs (well, covers) in English, but her best work imo is in French which the other two are examples of.

 

I was going to post some Celine songs but admittedly i'm not the most familiar with her music besides the hits. The only album i've listened to in full was courage.

 

3:00 is by far one of my favourite vocal moments of all time though.

 

[HninSi 430]

Power - Whitney

Range - Mariah

Control - MARIAH (Any other option is invalid)

Tone - Mariah 

Overall vocal talent - Mariah/ Whitney

With all respect to Celine, I don't really admire her vocal placements or her mixed technique.

[WinnieIsFree 19,654]

10 hours ago, Lynk said:

• Power - Whitney 
• Range - Mariah
• Control - Mariah 
• Tone - subjective but Whitney 
• Overall Vocal Talent - Mariah 

Mariah’s natural range is unmatched and so is her control. The amount of different textures she is able to convey with her voice, fitting to any genre, throughout her entire range is literally inhuman. She is arguably the most versatile pop vocalist of all time. The things she is able to do with her voice are far ahead of Celine and Whitney who simply do not have the ability. Her ability is unmatched, her lows notes are unmatched, her whistles, the ease she possessed in her upper belts, the control to switch between registers seamlessly one breath. She is the best mainstream female vocalist of all time. 

[jrdn 26,669]

10 hours ago, HninSi said:

With all respect to Celine, I don't really admire her vocal placements or her mixed technique.

This, i love Celine but her technique is not always the best. Sometimes her belts are too nasal/pushed (including in her prime), yet other times they're flawless.