Who has the better discography? Britney or Beyoncé?

[Strobo 2,262]

Of their whole generation, these two are the closest women to being considered legends by people.

But some people think that both of their discographies don't live up to that level, so who do y'all think has the better music?

[Urbi 55,680]

Beyoncé overall and it shouldn’t even be a question  

[Kylie 110,825]

I love Britney more but the albums you mentioned Beyoncé just wins  

[Strobo 2,262]

 

2 minutes ago, Kylie said:

I love Britney more but the albums you mentioned Beyoncé just wins  

This wasn't a setup I promise, I just couldn't think of any other pairs tbh. Bey and Britney have very different careers.

It's why I left an "overall" option!

[Tomás 23,305]

Beyoncé for all except for acclaimed, Blackout slaps too hard soz 

[Madonna 45,586]

1 minute ago, Strobo said:

 

This wasn't a setup I promise, I just couldn't think of any other pairs tbh. Bey and Britney have very different careers.

It's why I left an "overall" option!

Sure!  
This thread was birthed out of a discussion about Beyoncé not being particularly relevant outside of the US.

[Mario Spears 5,036]

DIL>BOMT

ITZ or ST? pretty even. love both but ST has my vote (i'd give it the slight edge).

Blackout or Lemonade? Again, i loooooveeeee both albums and i can't choose...but BLACKOUT has my vote (again, evenly split).

overall? BEYONCE! (ST and Lemonade are ULTIMATE CLASSICS!!!) but BLACKOUT, Britney2001 and ITZ>>>>>>>>

[Skyline 16,047]

Britney has a lot of good songs and In the Zone & Blackout are both great albums.

However, Beyonce's discography is just stronger overall. Also none of her albums are as weak at Britney Jean, so there's that.

[V For Vendetta 7,027]

Beyonce for every answer  

[Atlantis Princess 7,979]

Britney for earlier career discography and Beyoncé for late career discography.

I enjoy Britney's first albums more than Beyonce up until 2008ish but Beyonce in the 2010s just stepped up the quality. 

[Equals = 4,314]

Both

[Miss Icon 893]

Britney 

[Billie Frank 25,761]

Britneys singles shit on Beyonce's, but the latter has better overall albums. 

[StrippedX 5,120]

Beyoncé. 
 

People like to act like Blackout is all that and sure it’s a fun bop from time to time but compared to Lemonade it’s nothing 

[Billie Frank 25,761]

1 hour ago, StrippedX said:

Beyoncé. 
 

People like to act like Blackout is all that and sure it’s a fun bop from time to time but compared to Lemonade it’s nothing 

Lemonade is just as overrated, if not more so.

I do like Blackout but i don't think it deserves the hype, In The Zone is a far better album sonically and creatively.

[Chris 54,925]

I became disinterested in Beyonce after 2014

But I've always preferred Britney to Beyonce. 

[BreatheeOnKnee 478]

Beyonce takes herself too seriously for someone that steals other people's work and has ghost writers so Britney

[Urbi 55,680]

3 hours ago, BreatheeOnKnee said:

Beyonce takes herself too seriously for someone that steals other people's work and has ghost writers so Britney

I’m afraid you don’t even know what ghostwriter means  

[Urbi 55,680]

Also now that I think about it…

 

MC score: 

Lemonade - 92

Blackout - 61 

 

“acclaimed”???  

[Horn.E 5,432]

It's Beyoncé for me based on the categories that you listed above for voting. Britney has three completely mediocre albums back to back. Circus, Femme Fatale and Britney Jean is one of the most damaging run for an A-list musician. The former contains demo-esque (lack of) quality of songs while the latter two are reliant on the respective times they were released in (expired sounding is what I mean). Beyoncé only has two albums that don't do anything for me: I Am...Sasha Fierce and 4. However, there are still plenty of great songs in those albums despite the questionable production choices found on 'em.