Edge of Glory Impressions?

[temes 19]

It was flat and boring. I kinda liked the 'toned down' idea, but it didn't work in this case. The video would have been pretty good, if it was shot on real locations around NY or if there was more people in the video doing something. Only Gaga + fake studio set = fail.

[lucky 0]

Meh, I like it. I don't love it. Why? Because we were told of some fantasy art film about mermaids and some medical scenes, but we got her recreation of a scene from "East Side Story" instead +laughcry+

+legend+ always creating buzz

[Ana 18]

Your NO ONE to judge other people. Stop acting like she's a god, cause she's not. Like I said CLEARLY in my post, people overacted when the video hit cause we were literally waiting for hours for an epic video and we got this shit basic video. It's OBVIOUS that the heat of the moment, people are gonna say things they later regret. You have to take a seat and be able to take in negative criticism the right way. You can't come in here and tell those that said negative things about Gaga that they are psycho. Do you even know what that word means? Now that's out of the fucking line. Just cause you someone says "im done with her" you do no have the right to say they are mentally crazy. You need to get a grip and come back down from that cloud.

okay, so basically i am NO ONE to judge people but you go around and judge people every day. stop being a hypocrite. umm sorry but you NEED to get a grip if someone says that she needs to fucking rot in hell for a fucking video, that IS psycho and if you don't see you are obviously the one that doesn't know what mentally crazy is.

i didn't say that people that said they are done with her are mentally crazy, they just need to calm their tits, because it's just a music video.gaga has given us so fucking much this era and you are throwing her away like that? k.

and the only person that needs to come down from a cloud is you with ego that is as fucking high as a mountain.

what antagio said sums it perfectly up

Like Gaga said, this era will test a lot of her fans. Those who understand her message will remain by her side, while those who only jumped on the bandwagon because it was the cool thing to do will fall off and fade away. You don’t have to like everything she does, but as fans, it is our job to provide CONSTRUCTIVE criticism, all while understanding and supporting her. I agree, The Edge video is not her best, but it’s what she wanted and she didn’t sacrifice what she wanted and believed in just because the director and her team wanted to make this big, spectacular mini-movie.

[Moosu 0]

This topic makes me sad lol.

I'm about to watch it, but with all the disappointment? I'm giving up on the Fans more now. Srsly? I mean for me I see Edge of Glory to be a simple song. Not ohmygod in your face song. So I expect a simple video....

Sure the mermaids/fish/water/cliffjumping is a nice concept but I never imagined wtf it would all look like mashed up together. What would they do, cut her mermaid legs at the supposed set of the doctors room? Then she's back to life being a human? Wat? Then she jumps off cliff into the water cause she misses being a mermaid? No.. just no.

I'm probably gonna enjoy the hell out of this video, and I'm sure her 4th single will have the "monster" feel if she chooses what the fans chooses. (Honestly, Scheisse or Marry The night is the only 2 optional ones for now, save Americano for 5th one and let it be the 3rd sequel to Paparazzi/Telephone.)

Oh well

[Guest ♚]

The video is fun, and shows a new side to gaga. It takes some getting used to, but I like it.

[Gilly 12,318]

okay, so basically i am NO ONE to judge people but you go around and judge people every day. stop being a hypocrite. umm sorry but you NEED to get a grip if someone says that she needs to fucking rot in hell for a fucking video, that IS psycho and if you don't see you are obviously the one that doesn't know what mentally crazy is.

i didn't say that people that said they are done with her are mentally crazy, they just need to calm their tits, because it's just a music video.gaga has given us so fucking much this era and you are throwing her away like that? k.

what antagio said sums it perfectly up

Why the fuck are you talking to me like If I said shit like "Gaga needs to root in hell". I simply said "im done with this". Totally different. And why the fuck are you bringing in shit that I have done in the past? If I jump of a cliff, are you gonna be justified to do it to? Stop calling me a fucking hypocrite because this isn't about me. It's about you worshiping Gaga like she's some sort of God and thinking everyone that bashes her is a mental cunt. But anyway, I will stop arguing with you. I know what I said, and it doesn't make me a lessor fan. It was simply at the heat of the moment and you need to move the fuck on. Your a mod and you shouldn't be in here calling me a fucking "hypocrite" or talking shit about my "ego" because believe it or not, that is a insult and it's just to provoke me.

[Mrs. Puff 2]

The video is too basic for such an epic song, I can see how some people might like its simplicity though. However, I didn't want it to be simple :x and we saw her perform the song live with a mermaid fin and were told other things that led us to believe the video would be have an interesting concept involving mermaids and medical procedures...and it turned out to be her dancing on a fake NY set.. Which is obviously a big letdown for a lot of people who were expecting something different and idk.. great.

[HeatSeeker 189]

OK let's focus on the video now, and stop going at each other.

[Ana 18]

Why the fuck are you talking to me like If I said shit like "Gaga needs to root in hell". I simply said "im done with this". Totally different. And why the fuck are you bringing in shit that I have done in the past? If I jump of a cliff, are you gonna be justified to do it to? Stop calling me a fucking hypocrite because this isn't about me. It's about you worshiping Gaga like she's some sort of God and thinking everyone that bashes her is a mental cunt. But anyway, I will stop arguing with you. I know what I said, and it doesn't make me a lessor fan. It was simply at the heat of the moment and you need to move the fuck on. Your a mod and you shouldn't be in here calling me a fucking "hypocrite" or talking shit about my "ego" because believe it or not, that is a insult and it's just to provoke me.

i didnt? i said that those that did are fucking psychos. i never said that YOU said it, i don't even know what you said, i was reading gagadaily and tumblr, do you think i am following you around to see what you are saying?

umm it's not in the past when you were judging me in that post, it's hardly the past. you always act like this, so it's hardly something you did only in the past.

and yeah try doing what you do best, trying to twist people's words, i never said people that are dissapointed are mental cunts, i said they need to calm their tits. i said those that said those psycho things about her are mental cunts, so get it right next time.

and yeah i worship her like a god, i love her, but i am not someone that can't accept someone elses opinion, like you do, you are always the first one to jump on someone's opinion, especially if it's something you don't like or you don't want to read. or you also like to call peoples opinion not valid, because you simply don't want to accept that other people think different.

yeah nice card you trying to pull there. yeah i am a mod, but i am only human too and you are acting like a hypocrite. you came in here to call me out, so stop trying to look like the victim, when you were doing it first.

fine, i am done with you

[HeatSeeker 189]

Gilly, Ana, that's enough. Take this privately and get back to topic or the thread will be closed.

[Teenage Wet Dream 2,909]

lmfao how terrible

[Ana 18]

sorry diego, i answered after you posted it and i didn't see it before.

[Teenage Wet Dream 2,909]

i didnt? i said that those that did are fucking psychos. i never said that YOU said it, i don't even know what you said, i was reading gagadaily and tumblr, do you think i am following you around to see what you are saying?

umm it's not in the past when you were judging me in that post, it's hardly the past. you always act like this, so it's hardly something you did only in the past.

and yeah try doing what you do best, trying to twist people's words, i never said people that are dissapointed are mental cunts, i said they need to calm their tits. i said those that said those psycho things about her are mental cunts, so get it right next time.

and yeah i worship her like a god, i love her, but i am not someone that can't accept someone elses opinion, like you do, you are always the first one to jump on someone's opinion, especially if it's something you don't like or you don't want to read. or you also like to call peoples opinion not valid, because you simply don't want to accept that other people think different.

yeah nice card you trying to pull there. yeah i am a mod, but i am only human too and you are acting like a hypocrite. you came in here to call me out, so stop trying to look like the victim, when you were doing it first.

fine, i am done with you

LOL TELL HIM HOW U FEEL GORL +cheer+

[Gilly 12,318]

Moderator Notice:

get back to topic please

[aTunes 0]

The TEOG vid is the lowest point of her career so far, and believe me it pains me to say that. I'm just at a loss for expressing how disappointed I am. It's not even that the vid is bad (it's not), it's just SO boring and a massive waste of potential. I can't believe the whole lavish concept they had got scrapped. I just can't understand what Gaga was thinking when she did that. Oh well, the song is still epic and turning into her biggest hit of the era so far. No artist is perfect all the time, even Gaga. Maybe MTN can have an epic vid.

[Hussam 6]

While this video was REALLY BORING, it's still not as awful as Alejandro and Born This Way were... I also think that she noticed that being abnormally weird is not cool anymore and that's why she's toned it down in her last two videos + recent live performances

[IlContact 2.0 0]

I like it! it shows another side of Gaga and suites the song perfectly. Maybe not her best video, but i quite like it.. It's so '80 and reminds me a little bit of Michael Jackson's Bad Video

[JoeyCouture 80]

While this video was REALLY BORING, it's still not as awful as Alejandro and Born This Way were... I also think that she noticed that being abnormally weird is not cool anymore and that's why she's toned it down in her last two videos + recent live performances

Gaga is known for being abnormally weird and socially unaccepted. This video just has no meaning towards the song, it is nothing but her prancing left and right, touching her tits and gyrating her ass.Her lips are moving but she shows no emotion towards the song. Its all about "let me show off my leather outfit and how tight my ass looks in it while i rework my fame monster era wig." Seriously, what in the hell was this supposed to be in reference too?

I can understand toning down a video...but this song is EPIC. You do not and I mean DO NOT tone down a fucking video for an EPIC song! Was she seriously thinking her little monsters were going to just eat this video up? It is nothing but stock footage for those quick cuts to fill out a video. Anyone who thinks this video is gold is a blind fool. This video left me disappointed. Does she just not care anymore all of a sudden?

Rupaul has better concepts and her budget is 1/10 that of Gaga's! Jesus Christ!

Friggen snooze fest, seriously, I am all done with her for a while....all friggen done

[Happerson 3]

Okay.. WHAT have I just been watching for 5 minutes? Oh hey, it were the same four shots over and over again! :dead: Plus ONE outfit, ONE setting ohhh AND ONE SAX PLAYER!

[Happerson 3]

Okay.. WHAT have I just been watching for 5 minutes? Oh hey, it were the same four shots over and over again! +dead+ Plus ONE outfit, ONE setting owww AND ONE SAX PLAYER! Masterpiece +bow+

I actually was all for a more simple and basic Gaga video (after Alejandro and Born This Way) but this was not what I meant! I mean, I do believe that Gaga is very creative but that didn't show in this video at all! For such a great song, this was truly a snoozefest.. And her lipsyncing really bothered me as well! The lyrics are brought with much power and so in the song, but her performance was so flat :-/ No, this video is not good at all.