Madonna Album Ranking Megarate [RESULTS ON 1ST PAGE]

[Curtains 533]

The scores were calculated! I'll post the results of the megarate in a few hours, with one album revealed each 15 minutes!

[Vertigo-go 18,832]

I hope many of you voted, so the results will reflect the local community's taste to the full

 

[Curtains 533]

I had 20 votes in total, two others forgot to send me their votes on time.

I'm waiting a bit to announce the results so a lot of people can react directly to it.

[SeekingThrill 10,038]

 

[SeekingThrill 10,038]

18 hours ago, RoleModel said:

sorry... making this is impossible for me 

 

[Curtains 533]

Starting to post NOW!

[plutoniano 16,569]

is anyone else online right now?

how about posting the results one by one as different replies and once we're done you update the op?

that way we can react to the results "live" sort of speak

also, we could use the post for our weekly pointcounts

[Vilppu 10,032]

Masterpiece voted as the top MD N/A track?  

If you were the Mona Lisa
You'd be hanging in the Louvre
Everyone would come to see you
You'd be impossible to move

Y'all even read this?  

[plutoniano 16,569]

Like a Basic is her worst album fight me

[Vilppu 10,032]

Like a Virgin is so underrated, it's cheesy but fun. Dress You Up and Into the Groove are better than almost everything she released in the 21st century.

[Curtains 533]

As Lord Stoneheart suggested, I'll post them one by one here too!

[plutoniano 16,569]

Dress You Up the best track?

[Curtains 533]

#14 : 

Score : 5,30/10

Highest Rate : 8,00 (John Wayne)

Lowest Rate : 1,00 (Vilppu)

Favorite Song (Tie) : Masterpiece / Beautiful Killer (each 18% of the votes)

 

Fans described the album as a mixed bag : you liked some of the songs but considered some others really bad. Most of you noted how Madonna seemed to be chasing what was trending at the time, and considered the album generic and messy, with horrible production and awful songwriting.

Some did say that they found the album underrated and that it featured some great highlights and a few good ideas nonetheless, but it didn’t stop the album to be ranked at #14.

[Vilppu 10,032]

2 minutes ago, Lord Stoneheart said:

Dress You Up the best track?

Well, it is the best song there.

[Curtains 533]

#13:

Score : 5,51/10

Highest Rate : 8,00 (Anna-wa, Dawni)

Lowest Rate : 1,00 (Lord Stoneheart)

Favorite Song : Dress You Up (35% of the votes)

 

Fans described Like a Virgin as being « cheesy », « garbage » and « trash ». Most of you claimed that the album has a really dated sound (somehow more than her first album) and deemed the last part of the album as « total filler ».

Still, you remarked that the album includes some of the the best pop songs ever (Like a Virgin and Into the Groove were cited a lot) and that it is a fun pop record despite its flaws.

[Vilppu 10,032]

Just now, LoanSPW said:

the last part of the album as « total filler ».

Wait, just saw this. Stay > Like a Virgin, Material Girl, Angel and whatever else y'all stan for  

[Systemagic 5,459]

[Systemagic 5,459]

Beautiful Killer stays supreme

[Vilppu 10,032]

This is also such a sweet, underrated song, y'all do the absolute most on it.

[Vertigo-go 18,832]

Quote

Fans described Like a Virgin as being « cheesy », « garbage » and « trash »