Best Pop Comeback Album?

[Wonder 12,835]

Nearly everyone has had a comeback record. What was the best of them? 

[Carlos 8,453]

1989 is not a comeback, tho. It was a debut.

Out of polls. Anti cause I'm biased.

[Say Lou Lou 7,258]

I lowkey love the shade for Gaga

[Freaky Prince 38,421]

Confessions on a Dance Floor 

[Americunt 16,421]

Calling Fever a "comeback" is a little rich. Spinning Around, On a Night Like This and Kids were all very successful singles that were released in the era immediately prior to Fever, so....  

[Arya 8,984]

6 minutes ago, Carlos said:

1989 is not a comeback, tho. It was a debut.

Out of polls. Anti cause I'm biased.

Also Red was very successful... isn't it a comeback when a pop star has an incredibly successful album after the previous one failed to achieve much success and sales?

[Diamond 49,268]

Isn't Light Years Kylie's comeback album? Also how is Glory a comeback album when it wasn't successful?  

[Carlos 8,453]

19 minutes ago, Arya said:

Also Red was very successful... isn't it a comeback when a pop star has an incredibly successful album after the previous one failed to achieve much success and sales?

She never really came back with anything. She transitioned. It's her first pop album so why would it be a comeback?

 

[Arya 8,984]

1 minute ago, Carlos said:

She never really came back with anything. She transitioned. It's her first pop album so why would it be a comeback?

 

Let me edit then! If Red would've been a full pop album, with the same sales it had, then 1989 wouldn't have been a comeback, because Red was very successful. Get it?

[Kylie 114,879]

Anti  

[Rihanna 748]

Glory 'cus BJ was a mess and I didn't expect anything good after it.

[Carlos 8,453]

1 minute ago, Arya said:

Let me edit then! If Red would've been a full pop album, with the same sales it had, then 1989 wouldn't have been a comeback, because Red was very successful. Get it?

Why the mention of Red? 1989 is not a comeback, Taylor didn't left, unlike the aforementioned artists in the polls. 1989 shouldn't even be in the polls. Cause, objectively Mimi and Madge are the right answers here. xx

[Memorial Address 11,106]

Glory

[Savage 17,300]

I can't believe i actually did it, but i voted for Moo.

 

[Arya 8,984]

1 minute ago, Carlos said:

Why the mention of Red? 1989 is not a comeback, Taylor didn't left, unlike the aforementioned artists in the polls. 1989 shouldn't even be in the polls. Cause, objectively Mimi and Madge are the right answers here. xx

A comeback isn't when you leave and then you comeback though. It's when you release a flop album, everyone loses hope in your career, and then you comeback with an amazing new album that is incredibly successful. I mentioned red because 1989 was put in the poll, and I was just saying that even if Red would have been a Pop album, then 1989 STILL wouldn't have been a comeback album, because Red was very successful. Do you get it now?

[WarrenThanksYouAll 15,920]

Ray of Light.

 

[Carlos 8,453]

4 minutes ago, Arya said:

A comeback isn't when you leave and then you comeback though. It's when you release a flop album, everyone loses hope in your career, and then you comeback with an amazing new album that is incredibly successful. I mentioned red because 1989 was put in the poll, and I was just saying that even if Red would have been a Pop album, then 1989 STILL wouldn't have been a comeback album, because Red was very successful. Do you get it now?

It's really not that deep and I don't know you're being defensive, still 1989 is not even the correct answer. if she made country then that would have been a comeback. 

[Arya 8,984]

4 minutes ago, Carlos said:

It's really not that deep and I don't know you're being defensive, still 1989 is not even the correct answer. if she made country then that would have been a comeback. 

Oh my...

I'm not being defensive, I'm trying to explain to you why 1989 wouldn't have been a comeback album in any possible case, thus why it doesn't belong into this list. You're literally saying the same thing as I am, just changing 1989 to country instead of Red to pop like I'm doing, can you really not see that?

 

Edit:

And no, if 1989 was country then it STILL wouldn't have been a comeback album, because Red sold MILLIONS of copies and it was SUCCESSFUL. A comeback albums means that you make a SUCCESSFUL album after you FLOP. 

[Carlos 8,453]

2 minutes ago, Arya said:

Oh my...

I'm not being defensive, I'm trying to explain to you why 1989 wouldn't have been a comeback album in any possible case, thus why it doesn't belong into this list. You're literally saying the same thing as I am, just changing 1989 to country instead of Red to pop like I'm doing, can you really not see that?

 

Edit:

And no, if 1989 was country then it STILL wouldn't have been a comeback album, because Red sold MILLIONS of copies and it was SUCCESSFUL. A comeback albums means that you make a SUCCESSFUL album after you FLOP. 

 

Exactly, that's why the lengthy posts aren't needed. 

[Arya 8,984]

2 minutes ago, Carlos said:

 

Exactly, that's why the lengthy posts aren't needed. 

It was needed to explain since you wouldn't get the point, glad you finally got it though!